Labour announces tough reforms to the immigration system
By Ben Pettitt
Less than 100 days into her new post, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has revealed what she labelled “the most significant reform to our migration system in modern times”. The major overhaul announced on November 17th, titled ‘Restoring Order and Control’, marks a policy shift aimed at restoring public confidence on the contentious issue of irregular migration that has come to dominate political dialogue. Changes to areas such as temporary status, permanent settlement and family reunion have proven divisive not only with the public but within Parliament, as MPs raise concerns of the morality and practicality of the proposals.
Hoping to reduce ‘pull factors’, the new rules mark a shift from permanent settlement for refugees to a temporary protection model. This means the cases of those granted asylum would be reviewed every 30 months, and their protection withdrawn if their home country is deemed safe. The time refugees will face waiting for permanent settlement under this 30-month cycle has quadrupled to 20 years. While the government will hope these deterrence measures reduce incentives for people making the journey to the UK, research from the Home Office has indicated that deterrent measures have little effect influencing such decisions. Criticism has also stemmed from the concern that this bureaucratic overload will heavily burden the Home Office, potentially reducing its operational effectiveness.
Hoping to reduce ‘pull factors’, the new rules mark a shift from permanent settlement for refugees to a temporary protection model
As a counterbalance to a deterrence push, the government has committed to ‘safe and legal routes’ to the UK, which hope to create pathways for “genuine refugees” who deserve safety. This includes expanded community sponsorship, giving locals decision-making powers regarding the support of refugees. The hope is that this will empower smaller communities, however, critics have argued that this will prove divisive – it pits some communities against each other, whilst also reducing refugees’ capacity for integration, since they will be clustered in smaller pockets of the country. The government has stated that these routes will be capped, with modest numbers at first.
These reforms draw heavily from Denmark’s approach to irregular migration, with senior Home Office officials even being dispatched to Copenhagen earlier this year. The Danish model is attractive to this Labour government in two ways. It has demonstrated an effective reduction in asylum applications, reaching its lowest level in 40 years, and it proved successful for the Danish Social Democrats in regaining voters from the right of Danish politics by indicating a tougher stance on migration. Labour will hope that these tougher measures will weaken the looming threat of Reform UK by showing they aren’t afraid of adopting a tougher approach.
These reforms draw heavily from Denmark’s approach to irregular migration… it has demonstrated an effective reduction in asylum applications
Nevertheless, the Danish approach has faced criticism. The strict limits and waiting periods on family reunion for successful refugees, that the UK has emulated, came under scrutiny from the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), ruling that it violated the Right to Family Life (Article 8 ECHR). There is a risk that UK courts will trigger a Declaration of Incompatibility if they find the new Act to be inconsistent with the ECHR, directly undermining the government’s efforts.
Unsurprisingly, these reforms have been met with a diverse range of reactions from within Parliament. The Government will have hoped that showing their willingness to impose tougher measures would help win back some of the voters that have flocked to Reform UK, arguably the most vocal UK party on the issue of migration. Some have argued however, that this could serve to legitimize Reform UKs agenda, leaving Labour’s traditional base feeling isolated.
This can be seen through the internal discontent from multiple Labour MPs labelling the reforms as “dystopian”, “performatively cruel”, and a “profound betrayal of Labour values”. The Health Secretary, Wes Streeting, has publicly expressed that he is not comfortable with aspects of the policy. Within the North-East, MP for Middlesbrough and Thornaby, Andy McDonald, has urged the government to reverse these new asylum policies, reflecting a worry from other Labour MPs within the region who face growing competition from Reform.
Mahmood’s reforms are a bold step in tackling a migration system that dominates political discourse. Its success will be measured not only through its operational effectiveness but also its political ramifications.
Image credit: UK Home Office via Wikimedia Commons

