Death by design: How Israel’s new law creates two tiers of justice

By Ben Pettitt

On March 30th, 2026, the Israeli Knesset passed the Death Penalty for Terrorists Law by 62 votes to 48. Palestinians convicted of lethal attacks, designated as terrorist acts by military courts, in the Occupied West Bank may now face the death penalty by hanging, with sentences carried out within 90 days and no possibility of commutation. The law applies exclusively to Palestinians and does so within a military court system that convicts Palestinian defendants at a rate of approximately 96%.

On March 31st, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk demanded the law’s immediate repeal, describing it as “patently inconsistent with Israel’s international law obligations” and raising serious concerns over due process and discrimination. The 90-day execution window itself breaches international humanitarian law, leaving no meaningful timeframe for legal challenge. Compounding this, the law strips convicted Palestinians of any right to pardon or commutation, both explicit requirements under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, ratified by Israel in 1991. Furthermore, its exclusive application to Palestinians violates the fundamental principle of equality before the law, and the High Commissioner warned that imposing capital punishment on residents of occupied Palestinian territory would constitute a war crime.

[The law’s] exclusive application to Palestinians violates the fundamental principle of equality before the law, and the High Commissioner warned that imposing capital punishment on residents of occupied Palestinian territory would constitute a war crime

In the Occupied West Bank, two entirely separate legal systems operate side by side, one in which Palestinians face military courts compared to Israeli settlers who face civilian courts for identical offenses. Military courts provide no right to legal counsel during interrogation, a process in which Palestinians may be held without charge for 90 days, compared to 64 days for Israeli citizens facing security offences. The disparity is most starkly illustrated in conviction rates, where B’Tselem reports that 96% of Palestinian cases end in conviction.

Amnesty International attributes this figure in part to a system that routinely relies on evidence extracted through unlawful means. A Palestinian convicted of manslaughter by a military court faces a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, while an Israeli convicted of the same offence in a civilian court faces a maximum of 20 years, eligible for release after half that period. The Association for Civil Rights in Israel has further noted that the Knesset holds no legal authority over Occupied Palestinian Territory, meaning this punitive framework is being imposed by a legislature without jurisdiction.

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel has further noted that the Knesset holds no legal authority over Occupied Palestinian Territory, meaning this punitive framework is being imposed by a legislature without jurisdiction

One day before the vote the foreign ministers of Australia, France, Germany, Italy, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom issued a joint statement urging the Knesset to abandon the then pending legislation, explicitly noting its discriminatory character. Following the law passing, further condemnation ensued through another joint statement on April 2nd from Egypt, Indonesia, Jordan, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates. However, most notable is the failure of the United States of America to condemn the legislation, instead noting its respect for Israel’s sovereign capability to determine its own laws and penalties. American silence in the midst of widespread global condemnation leaves Israel diplomatically shielded at the moment the international community is at its most unified in opposition.

The passing of the law is the culmination of a yearslong campaign by Otzma Yehudit, the far-right party led by National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, who was photographed celebrating the legislation’s passage with a bottle of champagne on the Knesset floor. It marks seismic change in Israel’s relationship with state sanctioned execution, having carried out only two executions since the state’s founding in 1948. With the law now in force and no prospect of American pressure to repeal it, the question is no longer whether it will be used, but when.

Image Credit: Axadem via Wikimedia Commons