A question of fairness: The IOC’s decision to ban transgender and DSD athletes from the Olympics 

By Ben Pettitt 

On March 26th 2026, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) Executive Board approved a policy excluding transgender women from all female category events from the LA 2028 Olympic Games. Eligibility will be determined by SRY gene screening, described as a once-in-a-lifetime test conducted via saliva, cheek swabs or blood samples. This policy applies to all IOC events, including individual and team sports, but the IOC was explicit in stating that this ban only extends to elite competition at Olympic level and will not affect grassroots or recreational sport. Crucially, the ban extends to DSD women (female athletes with differences in sex development who have gone through male puberty), meaning women assigned female at birth are also affected. 

The decision followed an 18-month review process between September 2024 and March 2026, led by a working group of medical experts. The IOC’s 10-page policy document states male sex provides a 10–12% performance advantage in most running and swimming events, over 20% in throwing and jumping, and potentially over 100% in explosive power sports such as collision, lifting and punching. IOC President Kirsty Coventry defended the decision: “At the Olympic Games, even the smallest margins can be the difference between victory and defeat,” making female category protection essential. The IOC surveyed over 1,100 Olympic athletes, finding strong consensus that protecting the female category required clear, science-based eligibility rules. 

At the Olympic Games, even the smallest margins can be the difference between victory and defeat.

Critics have challenged both the legal basis and scientific justification of the policy. UN Special Rapporteurs stated that discrimination on grounds of sex and gender is prohibited, and that mandatory genetic sex testing raises concerns around privacy, bodily integrity, informed consent and data protection, particularly where athletes face ineligibility for non-compliance. The policy may violate the Council of Europe’s Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine and domestic laws in countries prohibiting genetic testing without a health purpose. Challenges at the Court of Arbitration for Sport are widely anticipated, with IOC President Coventry herself acknowledging that “any and all rules and regulations could always be challenged”. The encompassing of DSD women in the policy furthers complications. Caster Semenya, a two-time Olympic 800m champion assigned female at birth, is amongst those affected, despite having previously won a European Court of Human Rights judgement against equivalent athletics eligibility rules. 

The IOC’s ruling follows previous decisions from sporting bodies including track and field, swimming, cycling and rowing, all of which already implemented bans on transgender women who had gone through male puberty, signalling a broader shift across elite sport. The new eligibility policy also aligns with US President Donald Trump’s executive order on sports ahead of the 2028 Los Angeles Games, with the United States Olympic and Paralympic Committee having already confirmed sex-verification tests for female skiers and snowboarders ahead of the 2026 Milan-Cortina Winter Games. President Coventry does claim, however, that the policy predated any external political pressure. The Sport and Rights Alliance, alongside ILGA World and over 100 allied organisations, wrote to the IOC urging it to abandon the policy, arguing that the scientific basis for the decision was not as clear-cut as the IOC claimed. LGBTQ+ charity Stonewall warned that although the policy is strictly aimed at elite sport, transgender people at community and grassroots level would hear the message they are unwelcome in sport, describing the decision as one that “stokes further division in an increasingly polarised world”. 

Fairness is not a one sided concept.

The IOC grounds its desire to protect competitive fairness in the female category in the performance advantage data outlined in its 18-month review process. However, critics would argue that fairness is not a one-sided concept, and that, in this context, it cannot be at the cost of transgender and DSD women, many of whom have spent their entire lives as women and now face exclusion. The Olympic Charter itself, the IOC’s foundational document, states that access to play sport is a human right, thereby drawing the decision into conflict with the IOC’s core principles. Although denied by President Coventry, the alignment of policy with the political priorities of the host nation of the next Games invites questions that are yet to be fully answered as to external motivations for the decision-making process. With challenges at the Court of Arbitration for Sport anticipated, whether the policy is scientifically robust enough to withstand legal scrutiny, and equitable enough to deserve to, remains to be seen. 

Image Credit: Nathan Cima via Pexels