Ken Clarke: the life of a “political addict”

By Will Fremont-Barnes

As he embarks on what will, in all probability, be his last parliament, it is striking that Ken Clarke still finds himself fighting political battles over the same issue as when he first entered the House of Commons in 1970. “I am astonished that the European issue is still being debated in this country”, the veteran Conservative MP says with genuine bewilderment. “I’d have thought it was so obvious that our role in the modern world is to be a leading, influential player in a union of states across Europe.”

Many of Clarke’s colleagues do not share his ardent advocacy of the European Union. “The message that it’s all the fault of Brussels has some appeal”, he concedes when explaining why he finds himself increasingly in a minority within his own party. “Parts of the Conservative Party are seduced by the escapism of saying we’d be able to cope with all these complicated problems much better if it wasn’t for Brussels, and somehow we went back to the good old days when we were on our own.”

Clarke argues that this “nationalist nostalgia” must be viewed in the context of the rise of “populist protest parties” in Britain and across the Western world. Referring to Donald Trump, Marine Le Pen, Nigel Farage and Jeremy Corbyn to illustrate his point about populism, he observes: “what they all have in common is they have simple solutions for overwhelmingly complicated problems faced by populations who have suffered some hardship as a result of financial collapse and recession”. The re-emergence of Euroscepticism, he reasons, cannot be treated in isolation from the contemporary climate of populism.

Neither can Margaret Thatcher’s resignation as prime minister, which occurred twenty-five years ago this month, be dismissed as irrelevant to the party’s “mad obsession” with Europe. “The Eurosceptic warfare that broke out in the 1990s was, in my opinion, slightly tied up with the reaction to Thatcher’s downfall, and the feeling on the right that Euroscepticism was a way to avenge her.” Until that point, Clarke contends, “Euroscepticism had got very subdued”.

This reawakening of Euroscepticism had costly implications for Clarke’s own political ambitions. “I always hoped to be prime minister”, he admits openly, laughing that he “developed this bad habit of running for the leadership of the Conservative Party”. Clarke put himself forward for the job three times: in 1997, after the party’s eighteen years in power had ended; in 2001, after New Labour had recorded another landslide victory; and in 2005, the election in which David Cameron rose to the leadership. Was Europe to blame for Clarke’s triple defeat? “Totally. The party wouldn’t talk about any other subject.” Particularly on the first two occasions, Clarke felt that the elections “became an elimination contest between all the others to decide which Eurosceptic was going to beat me”.

Putting aside this disappointment, Clarke nevertheless continues to enjoy a career that has been virtually unparalleled in terms of its longevity and illustriousness. He has served as Secretary of State for Education, Health and, most recently, Justice, as well as occupying two of the great offices of state: Home Secretary and Chancellor of the Exchequer. Following his four years overseeing the Treasury, Clarke, in the words of the Conservative Party’s own website, ‘bequeathed to Labour a golden economic legacy’. “That phrase is frequently used”, he responds when challenged as to its veracity. “It’s flattering so I’m quite happy to adopt it.”

The secret behind this success, Clarke suspects, was based on the job security that “insulated” him from pressure. “I always reflected that John Major, having already fired one Chancellor of the Exchequer, would never be able to fire a second. I actually took some quite tough and difficult decisions, and never had too much trouble selling them.” His economic objective, “the combination of growth with low inflation”, was therefore easier to achieve than it otherwise might have been.

With that in mind, why did the Conservatives perform so badly in the 1997 general election? “The government was unelectable because of the state the party was in”, once again demonstrating the destabilising impact of splits over Europe. Furthermore, in response to opinion polls that put the Conservatives “miles ahead” on economic policy, “Tony Blair and Gordon Brown very skilfully said they would carry on with the same economic policy and would not change any feature of what I was doing. Despite all my efforts to make the economy a political issue, nobody was bothered very much once Tony and Gordon said they would stick to my figures.”

If the Major government was the most tumultuous in which Clarke served, he is in no doubt as to which was the most successful. Of the Thatcher years, he says: “it was the best government I ever served in by a long way. Margaret gave us all the courage of our convictions. She insisted that the government was going to do things which most of her colleagues agreed with but had got used to saying was not politically possible”. This conviction did not produce instant results. “By 1981 we were horrendously unpopular”, at which point there was little sign of the profound transformation to come. “Midway through was when we all began to realise that we were making a bigger change to not only the economy but the culture of the country than any other government since the war.”

Clarke’s own involvement in Thatcher’s eventual downfall was significant. He identified “hubris” as having set in towards the end of her premiership, remembering the specific point at which she began to self-destruct. “I heard her, over some completely inconsequential row about something in cabinet, suddenly say, ‘why do I have to do everything myself in this government?’ I’m sure that all of us, silently under our breaths, said, ‘Margaret, the problem is that you are now trying to do everything yourself’.”

Realising that Thatcher had “lost it”, Clarke makes no apologies for the forcefulness with which he advised her to resign in November 1990. As the first cabinet member called in to see the beleaguered prime minister, Clarke recalls the “robust exchange” that took place between them. “She wanted to fight again, and I remember saying it’d be like the Charge of the Light Brigade. She told me I was being defeatist. I told her she’d been defeated.”

Thatcher may have “run out of steam” after eleven and a half years in Downing Street, but the small state, free market ideology to which she dedicated her career has formed the basis of modern conservatism. Having been at the heart of the Thatcherite revolution, does Clarke suppose that the current Conservative government eventually will be regarded as similarly radical? “I hope so. It is certainly the case that, so far, the present government has achieved a remarkable recovery from the longest, deepest recession since the war.” Whilst recognising that there is “still a long way to go”, Clarke praises this administration for having “taken on an agenda of active reform in practically every sphere of government on a scale which most previous governments would have considered unwise”. He predicts: “If we do emerge successfully and get most things broadly right, we’ll achieve quite a reputation”.

Clarke served in the coalition government, first as Justice Secretary and then as Minister without Portfolio, until July 2014, which enabled him to dispense his “wit and wisdom” on colleagues who had previously been his subordinates. He chuckles when asked whether they compared favourably to his fellow ‘big beasts’ in the 1980s and 90s: “once you start thinking like that you should count to ten and realise it’s about time you packed it in”. He describes the current crop of Conservative ministers, somewhat unconvincingly, as “a decent lot”, reflecting on the surreal sensation of “looking around the table and realising you can remember all these men and women when they first started in politics or were political assistants to your friends”.

Clarke is one of the last survivors from the old days in which “people were too deferential towards their political leaders”. Citing the media’s obsession with the private lives of politicians, he worries that the opposite is true today. Although the “whole atmosphere of politics is quite different” now to when he first arrived, Clarke remains enthralled by the profession he first decided to pursue whilst still at primary school. “The fact that I’m still in parliament shows I’ve been a political addict for most of my life.”

Clarke’s political life has been fulfilling but is, as yet, unfinished. “I have a very good research assistant who keeps bullying me into writing my memoirs.” When pressed as to why he has not yet done so, he protests: “I’ve just been too busy. By the time I actually have all the time in the world to write my memoirs, I shall probably have lost my marbles and it’ll be too late”.

In the event that Clarke never writes a full account of his life, it therefore would be remiss not to ask what he considers his best and worst decisions in politics. He dwells on his achievements as Health Secretary. “My determination to embark on the reform that became known as the internal market, which has continued to be the basis of the evolution of the service ever since, was the biggest impact I ever made on politics, not least because Margaret Thatcher was quite resistant to the idea.”

When it comes to discussing his worst decision, Clarke becomes uncharacteristically coy. “I’m always very guarded about that. Nowadays, politicians are not allowed to get away with their confessions of failure, so I always say driving through the House of Commons the order that introduced road humps, which I did in my very first departmental job as parliamentary secretary for transport.”

This neatly illustrates how far the world has changed since Clarke first entered parliament. The nature of Britain’s relationship with its continental partners, however, remains as uncertain now as the day he began his long life in politics.