Kavanaugh v. Believing Women: A Supreme Court precedent
By Sophia Obrecht
6th October 2018: Brett Kavanaugh is confirmed to the US Supreme Court. The appointment was marred by weeks of testimonials, committee hearings and press coverage focused on the allegation made by Dr Christine Blasey Ford, that she had been sexually assaulted by Kavanaugh whilst they were in high school.
What does this case tell us about society’s attitude towards women, and how we engage with allegations
of sexual assault?
In many societies there is a tendency to disbelieve women, to conclude that it is the victims of sexual violence, who must be the ones lying, never those accused. Our society, and its leaders, motivated by power, wealth and influence don’t understand why a woman would be willing to come out in public, recounting their past trauma and risking their professional and personal reputation, simply for justice and for closure. Surely, they think, there must be something else they have to gain?

This means that women, even as educated and well-spoken as Dr. Ford, are often treated as the suspects in their own cases, often portrayed as delusional, damaged, or on the other end of the spectrum vindictive and fame hungry.
Throughout the hearing procedure, Dr. Ford was portrayed as an innocent woman, who had simply mistaken the identity of her real attacker. She was considered unreliable and irrational, simply because she could not remember how she got home after that night, which as an expert psychologist she explained as a typical consequence of trauma. This did not stop the doubts from Republican senators or even stop the President mocking her at a campaign-style rally, depicting her as forgetful and downright stupid.
The case tells us that women, and their allegations and experiences of sexual assault, are not important, not when there are political agendas to force through, such a nomination to the Supreme Court.
The limited and incomplete FBI investigation itself proves this: the FBI not only failed to interview Ford and Kavanaugh, but they also failed to interview 22 people listed as willing to provide relevant testimony.
Kenneth G Appold, who spoke publicly about hearing of the assault around the time it took place, was never contacted. James Roche, Kavanaugh’s former roommate claimed that the honourable justice Kavanaugh had ‘stood up under oath and lied about his drinking and about the meaning of the words in his yearbook’.
Time and time again women are shown to the second-class citizens expected to quieten down, get over it, and just move on.

Society finds it easier to dismiss women, disbelieve their claims, and ignore their calls for justice, simply because it is the easy way out, because who really wants to acknowledge the prevalence of sexual violence in our society? That would mean having to make meaningful change.
Instead, Trump decides to declare that it is a ‘very scary time for young men in America’, but what about women old and young, and the dangers they have always faced and continue to encounter?
Featured Photo: Ninian Reid via Flickr
Capital Photo: Mobilus in Mobili via Flickr
Swearing in Ceremony Photo: The White House via Flickr
