This house would decriminalise drugs: A tale of two speakers

By Jack Wild

The heart of the debate, at the Durham Union’s first event of Michaelmas, was one of state boundaries. Do we live in a country that allows private firms to take control of a lucrative market, or do we accept a paternalistic state with its assumption of absolute morality against individual choice? However, despite all this, the main takeaway of the debate was the different quality of the speakers.

Peter Hitchens, John Karellis and Ben Cooper argued the latter case. The arguments were similar for each speech, but it was clear who the master speaker was. Before the debate, Hitchens’s name had spread along the queue outside the Union quicker than fresher’s flu.

Hitchens dominated the debate. He owned the space.

Hitchens dominated the debate. He owned the space. Hand-balanced on the podium, he thrust his voice and body towards the audience. His deep-set, intelligent eyes skewered the room as he pointed out the hypocrisy of the debate. Most of the audience partook in illegal substances freely and without fears of prosecution. As the cathedral bell’s song hung in the air Hitchens’s voice rose to a crescendo, crushing both the bell’s and the Proposition’s interruptions. At times these emotional appeals were clumsy and blunted Hitchens effectiveness, especially when he wagged his finger at the audience like a prep school teacher.

Compare this to Cooper’s speech, also of the Opposition. Like Hitchens, Cooper cited the emotional toll of overdoses on families. Conservative clichés were plucked and dropped into the speech, such as the non-existent freedom to work hard and of the “British dream.” He also talked of protecting “ordinary, hardworking, everyday people,”- whoever that may be. His jokes comparing the debate to masturbation and losing his virginity seemed embarrassingly crass.

Both speakers played on fears of the irreversible nature of decriminalisation and “bus drivers,” to “teachers,” becoming addicts. Both had made the same arguments to restrict individual freedom. But Hitchens appealed to the audience when Cooper did not. Charisma is a very powerful weapon.

Hurley’s rambling delivery confused both the debate and the Proposition’s case

The same comparison could be made about the Opposition. At first glance, all the Proposition’s credentials seemed watertight. However, Hurley’s rambling delivery confused both the debate and the Proposition’s case. As Karellis rightly pointed out Hurley unhelpfully reframed the motion from one of legalisation to decriminalisation. This unfairly led the Opposition to argue against two motions, not one.

It also confused the debate as Hurley failed to specify the practicalities of decriminalisation. Karelis’s questioning exposed the differences within the Propositions’ models. Chivers and Barton proposed stringent regulation of marijuana whilst Hurley and Blunt argued for more liberal measures.

Meanwhile, Blunt’s and Chivers’s arguments were of practice, not principle. Decriminalisation is the most pragmatic means of regulating drug usage. Thereby declining rates of addiction, deaths from overdoses and the strain on public services.

Decriminalisation is the most pragmatic means of regulating drug usage.

The public sector is nearing a crisis. From 1990- 2017 the prison population doubled England and Wales and 15% of this population are drug offenders. The penal system needs reform, not more prisoners. According to the Oversea Development Fund, 58% of prisons in England and Wales are overcrowded. The Opposition’s call for greater criminalisation is not viable.

All of this was presented by the Statesmanlike eloquence of Blunt. Gowned in Durham colours, the fading dye was a testament of a veteran debater. Like Chivers, he accepted the hypocrisy of some pro-legalisation lobbies. But his main weapon was to congratulate the bravery of Barton. As a Public Servant speaking out against Home Office policies he had risked his job. Blunt’s coolness rescued the Proposition’s case, whilst his modesty upstaged Hitchens’s mutterings and interruptions.

For thirty years this debate has entered mainstream social discourse, yet it has only tentatively been broached within the political sphere. Until the establishment takes this debate seriously and reaches a compromise, the status quo will continue. Prisons will remain overcrowded. Meagre policing resources will not be able to strangle the supply effectively. Illicit drug use will continue to be prevalent due to the quasi- decriminalised nature of Class C drug use.

Hopefully this debate will move from Student Unions to Party Conferences

However, for a debate to occur debaters ought to not slip into tired generalisations like Cooper or Hurley. Nor should the audience be swayed completely by the charisma of speakers such as Hitchens or Blunt. Hopefully this debate will move from Student Unions to Party Conferences without losing the nuance or passion it possessed during this debate.

All Images by the Durham Union via Facebook