IPCC: Carbon-capture or face climate catastrophe
A report published in April by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has stressed that action must be taken to prevent atmospheric carbon dioxide levels from reaching 450 parts per million (ppm) – widely regarded by governments as a ‘tipping point’ towards climate catastrophe.
Since the time of the industrial revolution, global CO2 levels have risen from 280ppm to modern levels of around 400ppm. To prevent further pollution, the report urges a rise in the proportion of energy obtained from carbon neutral sources from 30% to 80% by the year 2050.
The report emphasises that there is ‘no option left’ but to store excess carbon dioxide in underground reservoirs using Carbon Capture and Storage technology (CCS).
Three methods are currently used to isolate and store waste CO2. The first method, known as post-combustion capture, involves burning fossil fuel in a furnace, then purifying, isolating and compressing the CO2 produced during combustion. This method is widely used as it can be retrofitted to existing power stations.
Two other methods, known as pre-combustion capture and oxyfuel combustion, are not compatible with many older designs of stations, but are integrated into many newer designs.
Both methods involve burning fuel in pure oxygen rather than in air directly, and capturing the CO2 shortly after, or during, the combustion reaction. Both of these methods are advantageous over post-combustion capture in that the CO2 is separated whilst still under pressure, meaning that further compression is not needed before transport. The CO2 obtained is also free from nitrogenous impurities.
However, initial air separation techniques required to provide pure oxygen gas are costly and require energy themselves. Indeed, anywhere from 11% to 40% extra fuel is required in order to separate and store CO2 produced during fuel combustion, depending on which of these techniques is employed.
Despite this, nearly all CO2 produced from fuel combustion is returned underground from whence the carbon originally came, in the form of either natural gas, oil or coal. CCS is ‘carbon neutral’.
Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage technology (BECCS) involves teaming this technology with fuel derived from plant biomass. BECCS is an attractive option as it has the potential to be ‘carbon negative’.
Whilst CCS integrated within a fossil fuel power station has the potential to be carbon neutral, CO2 is nevertheless still produced from an initial underground fossil fuel source. In the case of bio-energy, the biomass created for combustion is derived from atmospheric carbon dioxide by photosynthesis. Burial of the CO2 released post-combustion effectively enables atmospheric CO2 to be isolated and buried, whilst also being used as an energy source in the process.
It is important to remember, however, that carbon capture technology – BECCS or otherwise – is simply a healing strategy: CO2 that has already been produced is swept under the carpet and ignored.
Another, easier method of storing carbon underground is to simply not burn fossil fuel in the first place. Capturing CO2 and storing it underground requires time and energy, whereas simply leaving fossil fuels underground and not burning them does not require any energy – or indeed any effort at all.
It is ironic too that most supposedly ‘green’ CCS technology has been developed over the past decades as a strategy to improve fossil fuel-extraction yields from underground wells. Purified CO2 can be pumped underground to drive out any remaining oil and natural gas – fuel that would not be retrievable using previous extraction methods.
CCS is also fundamentally difficult to implement, as it does not provide any immediate financial benefit. This means there is little incentive for energy companies to raise their costs by introducing CCS technology.
The benefit from CCS comes, instead, from inhabiting an overall healthier planet with a better quality climate. These long term gains alone will not fund a global effort to store all waste CO2 produced from fossil fuels.
The only sure-fire way of reducing emissions is to put our efforts into fuel sources that do not liberate carbon from underground fossil fuel sources, where it is already safely locked away. Producing fuel directly from atmospheric CO2 – such as via plant biomass – is at worst carbon neutral, and at best carbon negative if combined with CCS technologies.
Whilst CCS may give us an excuse to burn fossil fuels without guilt, perhaps global effort would be better placed in further developing carbon neutral energy sources, and not simply sweeping our troubles underground.
Illustration: Patrick Brennan

