What makes Marius the giraffe so special?

By Patrick Brennan

A Copenhagen zoo has been subject to worldwide outcry after the decision was made to put down a healthy male giraffe earlier in February. The two year old animal, named Marius, was killed by bolt gun due to him not being genetically valuable enough to keep, in accordance with the zoo’s breeding programme.giraffe

The decision to kill Marius has resulted in zoo officials receiving a barrage of internet condemnation, and even death threats. Several other zoos had in fact offered to house the young male and an unnamed Beverly Hills billionaire even offered to keep Marius in her – presumably extensive – back garden.

My question is simply this – what makes Marius the giraffe so special? Why is his death important enough to prompt this vast ethical reaction from so many, when thousands of unnamed animals are killed for food every day? Is the fact that he was given a name reason enough to deem him more worthy of life than the average cow or sheep?

The giraffe was killed using a bolt gun, the same device used to slaughter cattle and other farm animals. This device, a small fire-arm aimed directly at the animal’s cranium, provides a quick death with minimal suffering, as the animal immediately loses consciousness. Bolt gun was preferred over lethal injection, as this would have contaminated the giraffe’s meat, which was subsequently fed to the zoo’s lions. A captive lion’s diet usually consists of wide variety of farm animals; from those eaten by humans, such as cows or sheep, through to horses and rabbits. A surprise portion of giraffe, whilst costing Marius’ life, did spare the use of other animal meat. Had Marius not died, it may have meant the death of an extra cow or two. Or even thirty-odd bunny rabbits.

Marius’s death also prompted an opportunity for the zoo to host a live action dissection, in which the public was invited to watch an expert pick apart and explore the giraffe’s corpse. Whilst the more squeamish or sentimental may not be interested in such a show, dissections nevertheless allow Joe Public a unique insight into animal physiology, the kind often reserved for documentaries such as ‘Inside Nature’s Giants’.

Of course these immediate benefits of Marius’ death – lunch for lions and a public physiology demonstration – are not necessarily enough to warrant an animal’s death in itself: there is the more relevant issue of why Marius was killed in the first place, and why ultimately it was the best thing to do.

Marius was killed because, due to space constraints, keeping more than one male giraffe in a small space is risky, as fights can easily break out and animals can become overly stressed. Whilst many places had offered to house the giraffe instead, most of them did not come close to meeting the strict levels of ethical conduct that zoos must adhere to.

A broadcaster was told by Bengt Holst, the zoo’s scientific director that these zoos “would not, for example, sign a statement saying they wouldn’t sell their animals to a circus, and we can’t just close our eyes and send our animals anywhere”. Other zoos, whilst ethically sound, were running the same breeding programme as Copenhagen zoo; so whilst Marius might have been bought some more time, a similar conclusion would have eventually been reached by zoo officials, and Marius may have eventually been put down anyway.

Zoos provide an important opportunity for scientists to keep a dynamic library of the world’s animals; much like the Kew Gardens seed bank provides a catalogue of plant species. Many endangered species survive the horrors of over-hunting and habitat destruction simply due to the existence of captive populations.

In doing this, it is important to preserve genetic diversity within a species: too limited a gene pool results in inbreeding. Not only does this limit the amount of genetic variation within a captive population, but inbreeding can in fact be very debilitating for animal offspring. Many chronic health problems found in pedigree dogs are simply the result of decades of inbreeding. Had Marius been kept as a breeding male in Copenhagen Zoo, any resultant baby giraffes may have exhibited similar chronic health problems.

An interesting final twist on this story is the case of a second giraffe in a second Danish zoo, whose name is also Marius. In a bizarrely parallel turn of events, Jylland’s Park zoo, located in western Denmark, was poised to euthanize (the second) Marius upon the addition of a new female giraffe to the zoo’s collection, due to his similar unsuitability for breeding.Whilst the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria recently announced that there were no plans to send a new female giraffe “any time soon”, the young male’s future is surely not assured.

Only time will tell if pressure from internet outrage and public sentimentalism will act to save this second giraffe from his namesake’s fate.

Illustration: Charlotte Gurr