Greg Dyke’s B team proposal addresses only half the problem

sturr

By Tim Stickings

The World Cup is still weeks away, but England are getting their excuses in already. Rarely have England gone to a major tournament with expectations so low. Every major bookmaker has Belgium as more likely winners than England. England’s demise will be met with the usual lamentations, as fans and pundits look wistfully over the water at footballing powerhouses like Spain, Germany and Brazil.

Even the optimists, believing that England can defy the odds in Brazil, accept that in structural terms the England team lags behind. Bulky strikers are preferred to skilful playmakers. Youngsters play eleven-a-side too early in their development. English football is run by clubs, owners and broadcasters, while the national team is neglected. The decades of hurt are bound to continue.

Hence Greg Dyke’s proposal this week that Premier League and Championship sides should field reserve teams lower down the football pyramid. The proposal aims at a favourite target of Premier League curmudgeons, which is the prevalence of foreign players in English football. By squeezing out English talent, it is proclaimed, foreign players harm the England team. Give promising English players a chance in lower divisions, Dyke postulates, and England’s problems will disappear.

“The introduction of B teams could cheapen the Football League”

The proposal has merits and weaknesses. A similar system operates in Spain and Germany, where reserve sides have helped youngsters develop into first-team players. Thomas Müller, Philipp Lahm and Bastian Schweinsteiger all featured for Bayern Munich’s second string. Lionel Messi, Xavi and Andres Iniesta are among the alumni of Barcelona B. The English youth system has produced few equivalents. Of the Chelsea side that won the FA Youth Cup in 2010, only one player (Josh McEachran) has ever featured for the seniors. Experience in competitive leagues, it could be argued, would kick-start such players’ careers.

On the other hand, . The lower divisions have a value in themselves, not merely as trial grounds for Premier League clubs. It would seem almost crass for an established League club to be denied promotion by a band of reserves. The teams would have no genuine supporters, weakening the atmosphere of lower league games. An average 662 fans watched Bayern’s reserve team in Germany’s fourth tier in 2012/13; Wolfsburg’s reserves averaged just 177. No club in League Two did worse than 1,600.

Either way, the emphasis on native players is too simplistic. The England team did no better before the foreign influx. England have qualified for five consecutive World Cups since 1994, after reaching just three of the previous six. That could be attributed to an expanding tournament, but it hardly suggests that the national team has declined. The England side at Euro 1992, the last tournament before the birth of the Premier League, was one of the worst in living memory, mustering just one goal in three matches. England’s weakness is not a recent phenomenon.

“The problem is not just that too many foreigners play in England; it is that not enough English players go abroad”

The problem is not just that too many foreigners play in England; it is that not enough English players go abroad. For most English players, a stint abroad is merely a lucrative way to wind down a career. Even then, a relaxing spell in Australia or North America is preferred to a genuine challenge in Germany or Spain, not least because it avoids the impediment of learning a new language. Emile Heskey has spent the last two seasons in the Australian league. Jermain Defoe recently joined Toronto FC and neither is likely to play for England again.

Tales of English players abroad are full of farce. Luther Blissett joined AC Milan from Watford, but proved so inept that some wondered if Milan had mistaken Blissett for his Watford team-mate John Barnes. Even more bizarrely, his name was adopted as a pseudonym by political activists, publishing radical literature under the name ‘Luther Blissett’. Paul Gascoigne fared little better at Lazio, greeting the club president with explicit comments about his daughter in pidgin Italian. At the end of his career, Gascoigne signed for Chinese club Gansu Tianma, who hailed him as their ‘spiritual leader’.

Joe_Hart_Euro_2012_vs_Italy_penalty_01

The trouble lies not only in the players’ responses, but in how we perceive them. Escapades such as Gascoigne’s are almost a source of pride. Good old Gazza! Amusing perhaps, but humiliating as well. They suggest a failure to engage with foreign cultures, a failure which makes it hard for English players to gain experience abroad.

A small number have succeeded: Kevin Keegan became a fan favourite in Hamburg, while Gary Lineker’s spell at Barcelona coincided with his most prolific years for England. But most English players struggle to adapt; their former team-mates take note, and prefer to stay at home. The problem perpetuates itself.

All the while, England’s opponents benefit from foreign experience, not least in the Premier League. There are more Spanish players in the Premier League now than there have ever been English ones in La Liga. Of Spain’s twelve goals at Euro 2012, all but two were scored by players with experience in England. The favoured Belgian side is full of Premier League stars such as Eden Hazard and Romelu Lukaku.

To be sure, there are improvements to be made by encouraging Premier League clubs to promote English talent. The sight of promising English youngsters on the bench, dropped in favour of overpriced imports, is not a cause for celebration. But protecting English players from competition will only expose them even more at major tournaments. Whether or not the B team proposal is carried, it addresses only half the problem. Far more would be gained by sending more English players abroad.

Photographs: www.wikipedia.org