How ‘Spencer’ and ‘Blonde’ construct a dangerous new manifestation of the ‘manic pixie dream girl’ trope

By Freya Williams

Content Warning: This article contains references to eating disorders and abuse

In the mid-noughties, American film critic Nathan Rabin identified the emerging trope of the ‘manic pixie dream girl’. She was the ultimate male fantasy – ditsy and naïve; sexually available (but not excessively promiscuous); she challenged the ‘nice guy’ but was well within his romantic reach. Fifteen years later, representations of her on screen are dwindling, as her gender stereotypic qualities become increasingly less palatable to post-MeToo audiences.

In her place, however, is emerging a new blueprint for female characters which, for the sake of brevity, we’ll call the Dead, Sexy, Suffering It Girl (DSSIG). The DSSIG is a global cultural icon whose suffering has been widely mythologised. She is beautiful, she is loveable and she is, importantly, dead. But not long enough for her to have slipped from collective memory. 

Spencer (2021), directed by Pablo Larrain, and Blonde (2022), directed by Andrew Dominik. are two of the most recent and prominent examples of the presence of this new, female victim to the male gaze. The former uses Diana Spencer as its DSSIG muse, whilst the latter focuses on Marilyn Monroe. 

The creative aims of both films have been explained by members of their production teams in eerily similar vernacular. Spencer screenwriter Steven Knight stated, “I wanted to take a picture of [Diana] at a particular moment when she was at her most under pressure and see if you can find the human being behind the icon”, whilst Dominik wanted to create a film “about the meaning of Marilyn Monroe. Or a meaning. She was symbolic of something.”

In both instances, the true identity of the DSSIG is simply a challenge to the narrative, rather than an automatic standard of authenticity that must be respected. Both Diana and Marilyn are “something” to be explored as “symbolic” or “icon[ic]”, rather than as full, complicated human beings. 

This fictionalisation of the DSSIG’s real identity is, to a certain degree, factualised by the visual components of the film. The cinematography of both Spencer and Blonde is hyper-aesthetic, meticulously curated to recall imagery associated with their protagonists. Nearly every shot in Blonde directly reconstructs an archive image of Marilyn, whilst Diana’s outfits in Spencer prompt the audience’s sense of déjà vu. 

An opportunity for the male filmmakers to explore, and fetishise, the suffering of the DSSIG

Whilst this largely serves to allow the fictional narrative to recontextualise and reshape the associations of the original imagery, it also creates an opportunity for the male filmmakers to explore, and fetishise, the suffering of the DSSIG. The promotional poster for Spencer has Diana crouched in a bejewelled, champagne gown. This still, however, though beautiful in isolation, in the context of the film graphically depicts her struggle with bulimia. 

The directors’ depiction of the DSSIG’s relationship with trauma is particularly problematic. In both films, the progression of the narrative is entirely defined by instances of distress. Diana is increasingly tormented by passive aggressive manipulation of the staff and royal family, whilst Marilyn sees no real relief from physical and sexual abuse.

That these are male directors exploring instances of real abuse makes for an uncomfortable context. Dominik in particular appears to revel in constructing “a punishment fantasy, or a sexual fantasy”, inserting a scene in which Marilyn is forced to perform fellatio on then-President John F. Kennedy – an event which never occurred in real life. 

These films contribute to and perpetuate the very institutional manipulation they allegedly seek to critique

The public perception of these women, and their identities, was largely created from curated media. By taking real people and (re)constructing abusive narratives, these films contribute to and perpetuate the very institutional manipulation they allegedly seek to critique. 

Evidence of this can further be observed in the characterisation of the DSSIGs. Diana and Marilyn are both portrayed as women who are infantilised by their trauma, seeking stability and support in male figures with a paternalistic (and yet simultaneously sexual) relationship to them. Diana yearns for her childhood home; Marilyn calls every man she interacts with ‘Daddy’. 

Through this, the filmmakers imply that women’s emotional distress is an issue of their (pornified) emotional immaturity, rather than as a reasonable symptom of continuous oppression and domination. The depiction of the DSSIG’s suffering as not ground in reality but instead through mental disturbances is also a prevalent stylistic theme in both films. 

Both Diana and Marilyn experience aggressive hallucinations and moments of surreal changes to their environment.  Marilyn’s embryos talk to her, and Diana begins to be haunted by Anne Boleyn. Here, again, the filmmakers double down on their assertion that female suffering is largely the result of a troubled mind, rather than demonstrating that it is has a tangible cause: the influence and control of patriarchal institutions. 

The concept of the DSSIG is not, in and of itself, inherently problematic. The film industry producing art that expresses, questions, and critiques the institutions that have caused women to suffer highlights an important shift away from a culture of intentional ignorance. But when this art actively partakes in the same behaviours and replicates the same perspectives, the degree to which this shift is genuinely productive should be questioned. 

Image: pure julia via Unsplash