Review: ‘Empire of Light’

By Freya Williams

Post-pandemic, there’s been a resurgence of appreciation within film of the cinema-going experience. There is a heightened acknowledgement that those few precious hours spent in the dark, connected to other viewers by the emotional peaks and troughs of film, hold rare value in a time where physical proximity, especially to strangers, has become tainted with implicit danger. Branagh’s Belfast, Hogg’s The Souvenir Part II, and Spielberg’s The Fablemans, all offer fond nods to the magic of the cinema screen. But nowhere has the phrase ‘a love letter to cinema’, been more liberally applied than to Sam Mendes’ newest offering: Empire of Light.

Its trailer hints at the velveteen comfort of an Art Deco cinema, a projector’s beam, and Toby Jones in typical mid-century, non-descript-English-man fashion, signalling ‘people who don’t belong anywhere else’. It’s all very coy. And Mendes can get away with it – after all, his last film, 1917, garnered ten nominations at the 92nd Academy Awards. By continuing his collaboration with veteran cinematographer Roger Deakins, he comfortably ensured that Empire of Light had a pre-established aesthetic merit. Making it his first venture as a solo screenwriter was the riskier move.

His execution amounts to a narrative that is meandering and unfocused

The premise of the film is not, in and of itself, uninspired. Having a cinema’s perimenopausal duty manager find respite from schizophrenic episodes and workplace sexual abuse through initiating a relationship with a younger Black man, at a time of piquing racial tensions, is by no means a trope-heavy tagline. However, it does give some indication as to the script’s potential (and realised) pitfalls, that of broad and complex themes expressed within a restricted context. 

Though Olivia Coleman (as Hilary, the duty manager) and Michael Ward (as Stephen, Hilary’s lover) certainly possess the acting chops to render impressive nuance and range to their dialogue, little can be done to disguise the cliched live-laugh-love-esque maxims they’re both forced to utter. There are multiple instances in which Hilary seems to be one ‘believe in yourself’ away from pulling out a bottle of fizz and announcing ‘prosecco o’clock!’. And then actually does so by taking Stephen to the cinema’s roof for an opportune New Year’s kiss.

Mendes’ keenness to explore so many intricate dynamics – age-gaps, inter-racial relations, mental health, gender power, and workplace hierarchies – is admirable. Unfortunately, his execution amounts to a narrative that is meandering, unfocused, and fails to accurately represent the realities of the way in which these intersectional issues affect people. To that end, some scenes offer uncomfortable viewing in light of Mendes’ status as a straight, white man. His portrayal of Hilary’s relapse with chiaroscuro accentuations verges on voyeurism and his implication that her inaction during Stephen’s assault can be remedied with the gifting of a vaguely sentimental vinyl record is reductive, if not obtuse.

Though its narrative and script are questionable, Mendes’ sensitivity to the value of the visual and auditory is notable. Deakins’ cinematography is undeniably beautiful: imbuing a heady nostalgia with close-ups, blurs, and gentle fractures of light. If his craft were the only reason for the film’s namesake, it would be justified. It’s the perfect blend of enhanced naturalism with artistic intuition, generating settings which feel carefully touched with an inobtrusive poetic gaze.

It’s the perfect blend of enhanced naturalism with artistic intuition

Composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross are similarly adept at using their medium to subtle yet essential effect. Their score is a delicate fusion of sparse ethereality – the morphing of orchestral flushes with minimalist piano melodies, sculpts a soundscape that offers a timelessness to its expressive arc. It’s the sort of score that could exceed its source film in its notoriety.

Ultimately, though, Empire of Light cannot be salvaged by simply looking and sounding pretty. Its lack of emotional depth and authenticity, its failure to say anything particularly profound, mean that it leaves its audience distinctly unmoved. Cinema Paradiso it is not, but if you’ve got a spare afternoon and aren’t willing to think too much about the film you’re watching, it provides an adequate time-filler.

Image: Jeremy Yap via Unsplash