Hong Kong: broadcasting the revolution
By Isaac Abraham
On the night of September 28th, two final-year journalism students at the University of Hong Kong set up a Facebook page with the simple title of ‘LIVE, Verified Updates’. A few hours later at 5:57 AM, Hong Kong police fired 87 cans of tear-gas into a crowd of largely-peaceful protesters who were occupying one of the city’s main thoroughfares.
Images of protesters using umbrellas to defend themselves against the gas proliferated rapidly throughout the world and the Umbrella Revolution was born.
Even though the world’s mainstream media had full coverage of the chaotic events that gripped Hong Kong in the early hours of the morning, lots of people were choosing to pay attention to what the Facebook page set up hours earlier was posting. In just 24 hours it had received 70,000 ‘likes’.
Part of the reason the page was successful was because along with news, it was posting valuable information relevant to those in the midst of the protests.
This included the location of first aid stations, details of disruptions to public transport, and information about cafes and buildings where people could charge their batteries — both their phone’s and their own — for a couple of hours.
However, this was not unique and countless other pages were doing exactly the same thing. What separated LIVE: Verified Updates from the rest was the emphasis that those running the page placed on one word, ‘verified’.
When LIVE was conceived, Isaac Cheung, a second year journalism student at the University of Hong Kong heard that its founders were looking for fellow students to act as editors and administrators. Cheung applied, was vetted, and has been working for the page ever since. Summarising the role of the page, he said: “Our job is to take those rumours that are floating around in Hong Kong, try our best to verify it, and then notify our followers about what is true and what is false.
The clarification of rumours is one of our core values and one that we have observed since the start of the page.”
In a dynamic, ever-changing situation like the Umbrella Revolution, the importance of separating news from rumour cannot be stressed enough.
Normally one would expect the traditional news media to separate fact from fiction, but in a country that ranks just 61st in the Press Freedom ranking and where a majority of local news outlets are owned by tycoons accused of being sympathetic to China, in the midst of the ‘revolution’ the public were, more than ever before, wary of large local news agencies.
When people looked for an alternative, they naturally turned to what now dominates our lives: social media. In Hong Kong it was Facebook, more so than Twitter, that ended up becoming a primary source for news about the ‘revolution’.
Uniquely, and most problematic, Facebook hosted news that not only came from semi-credible sources but also from individuals who posted whatever they heard or saw to their wider circle of friends.
As a result a large majority of these reports were tabloid in nature. These were often one-source stories which had little to no credibility but nonetheless were often taken for face value by those who read them, who then in turn spread it themselves.
A prominent example of this type of story that popped up from time to time were those claiming that in a Tianamen Square-esque turn of events, PLA (People’s Liberation Army) tanks were on their way to confront the protesters.
At first glance these posts, which almost always were accompanied by either a photo or video as ‘proof’ could be thought of as legitimate. Dig a little deeper however, and all of it was nonsense.
The pictures and videos were all old and PLA tanks were not going anywhere near the protesters.
In this vibrant social media news environment that thousands were using, the main thing missing was someone trusted who was essentially doing the job of old-media and separating true from false. This is where LIVE: Verified Updates stepped in.
At its peak, and when the revolution was most active, the page consisted of twenty editors camped out in a common room at the University of Hong Kong’s Journalism and Media Studies Center.
The editorial team’s primary role was to try and verify reports that they were receiving through the page itself and from various other sources. Cheung says that they quickly learnt to be very wary of certain sources, the most prominent of which was WhatsApp, where people blasted often unsubstantiated and politically motivated reports through huge group chats.
Verification of stories that the team pursued often took the form of an official statement from one of the groups involved in the movement or confirmation by one of the student reporters that the page had on the ground.
Ultimately, the editors had to be as close as they could to 100% sure that what they were posting was the truth.
Cheung admits that, initially, adopting the page’s ethos of only posting verified news was “tough” especially in a situation where so much information was flying around. Ultimately, the conscious decision the team made to sacrifice speed for accuracy was one that paid off.
By showing restraint and posting only verified news, even if it meant they were a little bit slower, the page was able to legitimise itself and gain people’s trust in the midst of what still remains an uncertain situation.
Photograph: Daren Leung Shi Chi

