The Palatinate Guide to the NUS Referendum
Contributions made by Palatinate News Team and Isaac Abraham
What does the NUS do?
According to the www.nus.org.uk:
“We fight discrimination, isolation and injustice. Through practical information and national action, we make sure students can thrive. We support and strengthen students and their unions. We are informed – developing research that influences national policy. We are active – taking on all the issues that affect students’ lives now and in future. We know students.”
The NUS claims its aim is to promote and defend the rights of students and students’ unions by acting as a national collective voice.
Those students’ unions that are affiliated with the NUS, including Durham SU, are provided with purchasing, support and marketing services. For example, attached to the NUS is NUSSL, the buying consortium wing of the NUS, which negotiates cheaper drink prices for a number of college bars at Durham University.
Another service provided by the NUS is NUS extra, a discount card that is purchased by students.
Affiliated students’ unions receive a fee for every card that is sold to their members. According to the NUS, NUS extra cards brings students over 200 UK student discounts from a number of stores and restaurants.
The card is available to all students, regardless whether they are members of a student union that is affiliated with the NUS or not.
Why is Durham voting on whether to leave to the NUS?
“Let Durham decide this term”
The “A Better Durham” campaign, launched earlier this year during the term, published an open letter addressed to the Durham Students’ Union imploring the Union to hold a referendum in order for Durham Students to decide whether or not the union should remain affiliated with the NUS. The letter was signed by 50 student leaders.
It read: “Recent moves made by the NUS, culminating in the election of Malia Bouattia as president, serve to misrepresent, divide, and marginalise many Durham students. We feel that a failure to act is a tacit endorsement of the disturbing direction in which the NUS is drifting.”
The letter concluded by imploring the trustees to: “let Durham decide, this term. We cannot stand by any longer as students are misrepresented and marginalized.”
The ‘A Better Durham’ campaign has been one of a number of student union campaigns nationally that have been established amid growing discontent with the NUS, sparked by the controversial election of the new national president, Malia Bouattia.
Ms. Bouattia has faced allegations of anti-Semitism due to actions that have dated back a number of years. In 2011, she co-authored an article where she referred to the University of Birmingham as “something of a Zionist outpost in British higher education”. At the time, the letter came to the attention of over 300 heads of Jewish Student Societies.
However, for the ‘A Better Durham’ campaign, along with similar campaigns at other universities, the motivation behind the desire to disaffiliate with the NUS goes beyond the controversial appointment of Malia Bouattia, although this is a significant factor.
Tom Harwood told Palatinate: “The election of Malia is merely a symptom of the fundamental and structural problems of the NUS, and its consistent moves to the extremes, misrepresenting students.”
Read Palatinate’s coverage of the emergence of the ‘A Better Durham’ campaign here
When is voting in the referendum taking place ?
Voting begins on 7th June at 8:00am and lasts until 10th June at 17:00
How can you vote?
Voting will be made available on Durham SU’s website www.durhamsu.com
The financial impact of the NUS
Student Union revenue
According to Durham’s SU, the union paid an annual affiliation fee of £38,570.45 in the 2014-2015 academic year.
However, Durham’s SU benefits financially from affiliation with the NUS from the sale of NUS cards and discounting commercial trade and well as the use of legal services or training received from Student Union staff and officers.
This academic year 5,133 NUS cards were sold for a revenue of £20, 117.17. Providing that this academic year’s affiliation fee is similar to that of last year, the revenue gained from NUS discount cards is approximately £18, 500 lower than the fee that Durham SU pay to the NUS to remain affiliated.
This figure, however, does not take into account the financial benefits gained other services such as bar subsidies.
Drink prices
The NUS provides bar subsidies via NUS Services Ltd (NUSSL) with its prime function to support unions’ licensed and retail trade operations, part of which includes negotiating deals for purchasing drinks. NUS Services Ltd currently subsidises some college bars and bars associated with Durham University.
An alternative buying consortium which arranges drink deals is TUCO, a university catering organisation. A number of bars associated with Durham University, including St. Chad’s College, uses TUCO as opposed to NUSSL.
If Durham Students’ Union were to disaffiliate with the NUS, it would subsequently mean that college bars that used NUSSL would no longer be able to do so, resulting in a potential change of price offered for drinks as well as transaction costs caused by the change between using NUSSL and an alternative such as TUCO.

Disclaimer: Not all college bars and bars associated with Durham University currently use NUSSL and therefore disaffiliation would not affect drinks prices at those bars.
Who is campaigning to remain in the NUS and what are they saying?
The main campaign urging students to remain with the NUS is called ‘Yes to NUS, NO to Disaffiliation”
Harry Cross, a prominent member of ‘Yes to NUS, No to Disaffiliation’ has said:
“The NUS has won major victories for students over the years such as Council Tax Exemption, Student Rail Cards and free Wednesday afternoons across UK Universities. As for the benefits NUS brings here in Durham, many of the resources for alcohol safety and mental health awareness campaigns come from NUS, as does invaluable training and support for our LGBTA and Students With Disabilities Associations, without which either group would struggle to function at the same level.”
“The sale of NUSExtra cards means the DSU makes a net gain from NUS membership whilst bringing discounts and savings to cardholders. Not forgetting, we pay less for our pints in the NUS, whose provider allows us to purchase alcohol and soft drinks at knock-down rates keeping college bars alive.”
“As a national organisation, it can be hard for the NUS to make the hard work it does year-round visible to individual students. That’s why those of us who support NUS have a responsibility to explain its benefits to students here in Durham.”
Millie Tanner, Durham Students’ Union President, who is currently involved in the ‘remain’ campaign told Palatinate in October:
“On the issue of relevance, I completely agree that NUS is not relevant enough to students at the moment. But I believe that walking away isn’t the answer – we need to stay in, stay involved and fix it from within – just like if you don’t like the way your JCR/MCR is being run, you pass a motion, or run to be President, or hold the officers to account. Our Students’ Union has considerable influence within our own University but will never have a voice on a wider level without the agency of our national union”
Who is campaigning to leave the NUS and what are they saying?
The main campaign to disaffiliate from the NUS is the ‘A Better Durham’ campaign.
Tom Harwood, leading member of the ‘A Better Durham’ campaign, spoke to Isaac Abraham about the upcoming referendum. The full article can be found here.
Harwood argues that the main reasons to leave the organisation are that the NUS is now seen by many as a costly, irreverent and unrepresentative organisation, which, critically, does not take into account the needs of certain minorities.
“One of the biggest problems is the way they treat minorities. They removed the automatic place for men’s reps in LGBT associations. They have been whitewashing their problem with anti-semitism, and they’ve just turned a blind eye to a lot of issues that are faced by minority students around the country.”
Harwood believes that to disaffiliate not only sends a clear message nationally, but also allows for a much more Durham centred student union. He argues that by disaffiliating, Durham University students are sending a message that they “have had enough of this costly, wasteful organisation. It sends a message of hope to other universities that they can do the same. Also we’ll be able to have a much more Durham centred view of things.”
“I think there need to be clear constitutional limits on what such an organisation can do and focus its time on. Also there needs to be a lot of waste cut back.”
Harwood argues that the remain and leave campaigns essentially differ due to the fact that the former believes that the NUS can be effectively reformed, while the later doesn’t. He said:
“I’ve not been presented with any evidence to suggest that the NUS has even the slightest inclination to address the real concerns being brought up by students around the country. I just can’t see how the NUS will fundamentally reform.”
Jack Gilmore, member of the ‘A Better Durham’ and DUCA, suggests that leaving the NUS will not only result in long term financial gain, but also kick-start much needed reform in the institution. He said:
“The point of the disaffiliation is, one of course to save ourselves money, but also what the NUS needs is that the disaffiliation campaign will give them the kick they need to break down and reform into something better or go through the reform process within.”
“The NUS should be debating the topics of rents, landlords, and they have had some campaigns, but they now spend their time debating on things like Syria and foreign wars.”
Hasn’t Durham disaffiliated from the NUS before?
Durham Students’ Union last disaffiliated from the NUS in 2010 after a referendum was called when pressure from the NUS caused a debate about multiculturalism at the Durham Union Society to be cancelled.
Controversy began when two executive members of the NUS sent a letter to the Durham Union Society which seemed to threaten violence if the debate — which involved members of the British National Party — went ahead.
The letter sent by the NUS attracted significant criticism for its strongly-worded claims, asserting that the NUS would be “mobilising nationally and organising coach loads of students to demonstrate at your university.” The letter also read that, “if any students are hurt in and around this event, the responsibility will lie with you”.
The debate was subsequently cancelled after the University deemed it a safety risk to go ahead. An internet campaign, known as “Durham University Students for Freedom of Speech,” was set up in response and attracted several thousand members.
In recognition of the high-profile case, the then NUS President Wes Streeting visited Durham to address the issue in front of a crowd of around 300 students. Although he agreed that the NUS had made a “huge, monumental cock-up,” Streeting’s appearance did little to appease students and a petition was filed shortly afterwards, prompting the referendum.
NUS Disaffiliation Nationally

What is required for a vote to succeed?
For any position on the referendum to pass that position must receive the majority of votes from at least 5% of the members of the Durham Student’s Union.
When will the result be announced?
The results will be announced by the Durham Students’ Union at 18:00 on 10th June
Illustration: Olivia Howcroft
Infographics: Harrison Smart
