Analysis: Debating divestment
By Isaac Abraham
Perhaps what surprised everyone the most at the end of St Chad’s College’s termly Café Ethique on 2 February was how much both sides of the divestment debate agreed with each other.
Hours after he appeared in front of the University Executive Committee for its first discussion of divestment from fossil fuels, Professor Jon Gluyas from the Earth Science Department spoke to an audience at Chad’s about climate change, divestment, and what should be done to create a carbon free future.
In attendance was a considerable cohort from Durham’s People & Planet society, the group spearheading the Divest Durham campaign and in opposition to Professor Gluyas’ position.
Gluyas has been the most prominent voice casting doubt over the potential effectiveness of divestment, while the Durham Divest campaign has gained popular traction with support from nine common rooms and over 1,500 students.
After opening with a general overview of the climate situation and pointing to the fact that fossil fuels play some role in all aspects of our lives, Gluyas moved to the crux of his argument.
He explained how the major private oil companies that the divestment movement targets own only about a fifth of the oil reserves, with the remainder held by various state companies.
Gluyas suggested that owing to this small proportion, efforts to remove capital from these companies were misdirected, with the real power for change lying with governments.
Renaming Thatcherism and Blairism ‘Oil-ism’ and ‘Gas-ism’ respectively, he alluded to the relationship between periods of prosperity in the UK and increased investment in fossil fuel extraction.
For things to change, Gluyas said, the government had to start investing in alternatives, taxing fossil fuels and being the real instigator of change. Only then would big oil companies follow suit.
Alluding to the central role played by the government, Gluyas attacked the current government for removing alternative energy subsidies and decreasing its investment in carbon capture research.
Questions from this point on came thick and fast from the audience. One in particular related to the effectiveness of lobbying the government, and whether average citizens had the ability to actually push through such an agenda.
The most prevalent question however, came from the various People & Planet members in the audience.
Picking up on Gluyas’ statement that divestment was misguided, he was pressed on what he viewed as the correct way forward.
Perhaps indicative of the state of the current discussion around divestment, Gluyas was ambiguous in stating that he did not know and that “divestment may be the wrong method but it might just work”.
Photograph: Freya Palmer
