Ghosts review: ‘compelling’

Jesse Smith (Helen Alving) and Chris Yeates (Oswald)
Jessie Smith (Helen Alving) and Chris Yeates (Oswald)

By Simon Fearn

As every first year Durham English student knows, Ibsen’s Ghosts made a somewhat controversial debut, prompting an enraged Daily Telegraph reviewer to refer to it as ‘a dirty act done publically’. Collingwood Woodplayers’ production ensured the shock value the play had in the 19th Century was still tangible for a modern audience. Dealing with domestic abuse, incest and euthanasia, there’s very few controversial issues the play doesn’t touch on. Whilst this production did little to lighten the load of misery Ibsen places on his unwitting audiences, some excellent naturalistic acting and a surprisingly lavish set ensured that the action was never less than compelling.

The setting of Collingwood dining hall doesn’t exactly promise much, and isn’t the ideal venue for an intimate, domestic drama, but you’d be surprised. The backdrop may have looked like the cover of a Jane Austen novel, but the decision to have the two halves of the audience facing each other managed to create a sense of closeness, and sometimes claustrophobia. The widespread use of red and the decision to stage the action in a half-light added to the general despair, and emphasised the fact that the action takes place over one, hellish night. I could enthuse about how the literal shadows represented deeper metaphorical shadows of the past tainting the present, but I’ll spare you.

Thankfully, there was just enough light to make out some terrific acting. Jessie Smith took on the iconic role of Helen Alving with aplomb, communicating her immense emotional strain with her electric eyes and giving the audience a sense of Mrs Alving’s more advanced age without overdoing it. She managed to communicate Helen’s extraordinarily bravery, yet could candidly admit her own cowardice. Chris Yeates was similarly excellent as her son Oswald, communicating a natural stage presence right from the moment he entered and proceeded to sit enigmatically in an armchair. He was adept in mapping the subtle shifts in Oswald’s character, making him morally ambivalent throughout and capable of constantly surprising the audience.

The supporting cast were on the whole equally wonderful, my favourite being Matt Beebee as the bigoted Pastor Manders. He managed to introduce a shot of bumbling comedy into a broadly unsympathetic character, and was persuasive as a good man who had been poisoned by the prejudices of his time. Arthur Lewis, on the other hand, played the amoral Engstrand as a Dickensian villain (complete with cockney accent), which jarred a little with the naturalistic and understated performances of the rest of the cast. It was amazing that Mrs Alving let him into her house when everything about him screamed wrong-‘un, never mind the fact that Pastor Manders seemed to be his best friend. Saying this, he brought to life Ibsen’s irresistible irony as he bewilderingly persuaded the priest to finance a brothel.

On the whole, it was an excellent and slick production, intelligently directed by Osha Al-Mossallami. A 19th Century play is in danger of coming across as dry and dusty, yet she kept her production organic and at times fiercely emotional. Ibsen’s copious dialogue was always going to be a challenge, but Al-Mossallami allowed it to be choked by tears and overlap as confrontations came to a head.

My only minor gripe is that more wasn’t done to relieve the heavy social commentary with more of an emphasis on Ibsen’s humour. For such an utterly miserable play, some moments are tremendously funny. My favourite one-liner is when Manders responds to the revelation that Oswald visits couples ‘living in sin’ at weekends with a pithy ‘Sunday of all days’. I was almost alone in laughing at this hilarious comeback, and more could have been done to let the audience know it was OK to laugh amidst the death and the misogyny.

Although there was no relief from the unrelenting melancholy, I was shocked, enthralled and eventually brought to tears. Despite Alisha Hallwood’s fabulous selection of period costumes, this was a far cry from a dusty period drama. The cast and production team all clearly love Ghosts and have given a lot of thought to doing justice to Ibsen’s masterpiece. All in all, a resounding success.

Until 15 June at Collingwood College. 

Photo: Katie Reade