One Small Step review: “pernicious problems”
By Simon Fearn
I wanted to love One Small Step so badly, yet despite my heartstrings being mercifully manipulated, I never felt that I wholeheartedly could. I think I’m out on a limb here, most of the audience maintained a reverent silence throughout and had nothing but praise for the production after the curtain had fallen. Nevertheless, I’ll plough on regardless.
On many levels, the play was theatrical gold. Both Annie Davison and Dominic McGovern mastered that flatness of tone people have when desperately trying to keep their head in the face of overwhelming emotion. Some scenes were utter perfection, such as an awkward telephone conversation between McGovern’s Euston and his dying sister Steph that was choked with all the things that were left unsaid.
The dialogue and the performances were understated throughout, with the writing for the most part clear-headed and well-observed. Rohan Perumatantri was not afraid of dealing with some difficult questions, such as the right the loved ones of a terminally ill patient have to their own happiness. Perumatantri was also very brave in making his heroine far from perfect—although our sympathy is never allowed to wander far away from Steph, we are still very conscious of her flaws and occasional selfishness.
The staging was also shot through with a sense of wonder. In the closing scene, the ‘stars’ that appeared in the backdrop added a sense of transcendental beauty to the play’s harrowingly climax. The scene in which Steph falls into a final coma is handled inventively and respectfully, and after seeing this play I will never be able to listen to Space Oddity again without a lump in my throat.
The harrowing subject matter, however, masked some pernicious problems. Perumatantri’s dialogue had an unfortunate habit of relying on mundane anecdotes to build the sibling’s relationship, but these were were so unimaginative and every-day that they failed to leave any emotional impact. Perumatantri’s attempts to save the play from being unremittingly bleak felt a little forced, and his eagerness to give each character a lengthy closing monologue, including the now-dead Steph, wrapped things up a little too neatly for my tastes.
Davison’s performance, although utterly stellar for the most part, occasionally fell uncharacteristically flat. Her attempts to portray Steph’s impetuosity and lust for life via motor-mouth monologues and winning smiles all felt a little false, and sometimes even a little stagey. These initial misgivings were overcome by the end of the play, which Davison made tremendously difficult to watch. McGovern spent much of the play in her shadow, only really holding his own in his honest and well-written final monologue.
One Small Step was by no means a bad play, and it approached a difficult subject in a simple and honest way. It’s just that we shouldn’t let the havoc the play wreaks on our emotional wellbeing allow us to overlook its shortcomings.
Photograph: Samuel Kirkman
The Durham Drama Festival will run until Fri 12th Feb at The Assembly Rooms Theatre. Tickets will be available on the door.
