For a politicised Palatinate

By Jade Frances Azim

I understand the sentiment of Josh Smith’s editorial on defence of old school student media. For one, it is not lost on me that Palatinate did indeed report on the causes that I championed during my campaign for DSU President. I often have written for Palatinate, using it as a platform for the causes I hold dear, and the causes of my society. It is a great sounding board and has a decent reach.

But there is a point when this editorial gave off a slightly snobby feeling, one of a reluctance to see Palatinate’s weaknesses and where it could improve, and how it can compete with new media like, but not limited to, The Tab.

This is a question that haunts old media across the land. The latest casualty to the ruins of new media was the near century-old Independent, cannibalised by its more concise and digitalised sister, the ‘i’. Outlets that do not recognise the danger are doomed to fail. But the challenge is identifying and diagnosing the problem, and understanding why more and more readers are drawn to newer outlets.

I think the answer is that we demand more and more provocation. As much as we may slander and hold disdain for outlets such as the Tab, we continue to read them nevertheless. Their controversies go viral, and they reap the reward in hits, regardless of the comments section. Its power lies in whispers, gasps and Yaks.  The greatest difference between Palatinate and The Tab is not what issues they cover, or covering ‘the stories you care about’; it’s how they cover them.

Palatinate, and most student media, prides itself on its independence. It kicks against the grain and should stir provocation against the powerful, as its job entails. It is the prime platform for holding all forms of authority within the University to account. Campus campaigns are kick-started there. It gives exposure to issues and at its best, its investigative journalists find secrets we were not meant to see. But it is not enough.

While its comment section is rife with opinions, some of which elicit controversies, Palatinate itself leaves the controversies to its writers; Palatinate itself – like many of its counterparts nationwide – refuses to hold explicit positions of its own. In some ways, this is to maintain independence, but in others, it betrays it. There is little doubt that the editorial board holds opinions. Whether that be an opinion on a presidential candidate, on the University, on the DSU, or on a campaign, the editorial board are as opinionated as you or I. Trying to suppress this is a mistake. And denigrating other boards for the same is not a proof of prestige or a vindication of independence, it is evidence of the opposite.

Readers like opinions and they like debate, no more so than in University. The Sun, as much as I as a Labour activist disagree with it, is read so widely because it reflects the views of a certain segment of the population. People read it to nod along to its words and to share it with friends and families in disgruntled ‘have you seen this?’s.

Palatinate, in rising above the fray, condemns itself to that grey area of not being controversial or provocative at all. It is a weakness, not a strength.

And we need provocation right now, and we need it from a respected outlet. The University is getting away with murder; many students feel the DSU is letting it. The NUS embroils itself in division, while the government legislates for more damage done to our education. No matter what side of the debate Palatinate takes – though I fear it being a voice of the ‘Establishment’- it is vital that it as a united voice takes a side to begin with. Dedicating its front pages to ‘Palatinate endorses…’ this campaign, or that candidate; running its own campaigns and using its power and circulation to rally support. It can be so much more if it lends itself a voice.

This is by no means me saying ‘golly God, I wish they endorsed me!’. I don’t care much for that. On the contrary, had it endorsed my rival, that would have made the campaign every bit more interesting, and would have forced me to be a better candidate. It would have strengthened democracy and the power of students. It is about getting the most out of accountability, and ensuring students are every bit as powerful as the forces of the University. Palatinate is a vital instrument in that.

In order to prove not just its independence, but also ensure its survival, Palatinate must politicise itself.

Image: Palatinate