In defence of ‘old-school student media’
By Josh Smith
The Guardian published an article last month on the success of The Tab, claiming that the online tabloid is squeezing out ‘old-school student media’. If this is true, get me the hell out of here.
The Tab recently posted a harrowing account of someone whose friend tried to kill herself. The article was incredibly important, both for highlighting the University’s insufficient resources for dealing with these situations and for affirming student media as one of the few outlets to discuss this. The link to the article can be found here and I recommend that everyone reads it.
Despite this, the way in which The Tab (and by this I mean The Tab Durham) cherry-picks critical issues to report on, and sensationalises them to the point of hysteria, should be a red card for student media.
At the time of writing, two of The Tab’s ‘stories you care about’ are ‘Which Means Girls character is your college?’, and the predicted winner of this year’s student media award, ‘Why you should let the Turtleneck into your hearts’. This light-hearted style of journalism is something Palatinate can learn to do better, but please don’t lump us in with The Tab for the title of serious student journalism.
Looking back over the last year, Palatinate’s coverage of student life has been ground-breaking. In 2015 Palatinate covered every aspect of river safety, constantly probing the University over the likelihood of reform and working with the City Safety Group to ensure the legislation of effective measures. Last Easter we revealed the University’s shameful investment in defence contractors and chemical companies. We also exposed the University’s gender and ethnicity pay gap nine months before the University and College Union did (a report The Tab used this week to claim a 5% pay gap, branded a “load of horse bollocks” and “intellectually disingenuous” in the comments).
The Guardian claims traditional student media is struggling to keep up, but is this observation completely founded? We are never going to get as many views as The Tab, nor match their profound insights into the gripping realities of student life (“FINALLY: Deliveroo has arrived in Durham”). Click-bait has a place, but so does serious student journalism. The Daily Mail gets more views than The Guardian; is this a reliable guide to the quality of the respective publications?
I myself sometimes indulge in fittest Fresher or surveys of students’ biro preferences, in those moments of truly desperate procrastination; I just feel that serious student journalism also has a place alongside entertaining crap. The most irritating Tab article I have read concerned its backing of Jade Azim in the latest SU elections, citing her promises for change in detail (living wage, accommodation fees, divestment). Palatinate had been reporting on these issues for months before these pseudo-hipster bandwagon jumpers appointed themselves champions of the oppressed masses in the hope of getting a few more clicks.
Not that you have to report on these topics, and not everybody will be interested in all of these issues all of the time, but Palatinate has a role to play, and tries as best as possible to represent a cross-section of views held by Durham students. I feel like this sometimes gets lost, and wanted to use my final editorial to draw attention to some of the great work Palatinate does, and will continue to do so in the future.
Photograph: Christopher Somers
