Naz Shah: Anti-Semitism and Labour

By Archie Hill
Oh, how they cheered. The roars from both benches filled the Commons when, last July, Naz Shah, the newly elected Labour MP for Bradford West stood to make her maiden speech. The man she had replaced, George Galloway, was surely the most universally disliked man in Westminster; a delusional bully and rampant narcissist who, when he wasn’t too busy dressing up in a spandex cat-suit on Celebrity Big Brother, spent his time cosying up with every dictator from Baghdad to Benghazi. He now stalks the streets of London as a candidate for the Mayoral election; a fedora-clad has-been, occasionally yelling at passers-by, currently slumping at 0% in the opinion polls.
But, in July 2015, this was all still to come. For now, MPs were celebrating the new member for Bradford West. Unlike her predecessor, who had built a political career out of stirring up racial enmity in constituencies with a large Muslim population, Ms Shah seemed a more tolerant, inclusive representative. In her speech she attacked Galloway’s more openly offensive statements, in particular his unabashed anti-Semitism, hidden none-too-well behind the mask of what he and so many other bigots call ‘anti-Zionism’. As has been written elsewhere in the Palatinate recently, this barely-concealed prejudice towards Jewish people is spreading; amongst the censorious left-wing as well as more hard-line conservative Muslim communities.
And so the arrival of Naz Shah into the House of Commons seemed such a relief: out with the demagoguery and bile, in with pluralism and common decency. Hooray, cried the honourable members, the bogeyman was slain.
And yet. And yet. With an inevitability worthy of a Shakespearean tragedy (or perhaps comedy would be more fitting), the giant-killer has been hoist on her own petard. After a recent impassioned speech condemning the rise in anti-Semitism amongst members of her party, the new member for Bradford West seems depressingly similar to the old one. Facebook posts from 2014 have surfaced, in which she likened Zionism to al-Qaeda and calls for the ‘transportation’ – a hugely, painfully loaded word considering the context – of Jews from the Middle East. They could, she said, relocate to America. There was plenty of room for them there. She would lobby the Prime Minister. ‘Problem solved!!!’ she posted. She even added a smiley face for good measure.
As a member of the House of Commons home affairs select committee currently conducting an inquiry into the rise of anti-Semitism, this now raises the none-too edifying prospect of seeing Naz Shah forced to investigate herself for these alleged crimes. It also raises a fairly serious question: what next? If even those trying to heal the divisions in society aren’t above the occasional inane and ignorant burst of prejudice towards Israelis, as well as Jews in general, then what hope is there? Unlike Galloway, a man so preposterous that practically everyone ignored him anyway, Naz Shah’s position as an elected representative is significant. She matters.
Bradford is a traditionally left-wing stronghold with a fast-growing Muslim population, which currently stands at just under 25%. The vast majority of them are of Pakistani heritage, Ms Shah being one of their number. Given the intense hostility of many Pakistanis towards Jews in Israel and around the world, coupled with the rise of hate preaching amongst Wahhabis and other conservative Islamic sects in Britain, people like Naz Shah are needed more than ever to fight the anti-Semitic ignorance and lazy prejudice.
Now the cheers which once greeted her have died away: like so many politicians before her, she sewed the wind; now she is reaping the whirlwind. But all is not lost for the new member for Bradford West. She could apologise and try to move on as quickly as possible, or she could engage the conflict head on. If she truly believes in saving her party and her country from the poison of anti-Semitism she could – and should – go back to all her old friends with whom she was busily sharing Zionist conspiracy theories on social media, and show them the error of their ways. When she posts this rubbish she speaks, whether she knows it or not, for large swathes of the ill-informed and prejudiced. If they don’t listen to her, what chance is there for the rest of us?
Photograph: Vince Millet via Flickr.
