Finding the plot

EK Prout_Finding the Plot_May 2014

By Michael Grant

More than 2,000 years ago, Aristotle argued that drama consists of six main elements, of which plot is the most important. Since then, vast numbers of writers and theorists have tried to elaborate on his ideas. What is it that makes a good plot? Why do some tales affect us deeply whereas others leave us cold? And is it possible to devise a general formula which could guarantee a gripping storyline every time?

One notable attempt to answer these questions was made by Gustav Freytag in the 19th century. By comparing the storylines of ancient Greek and Shakespearean dramas, he was able to break plot down into five basic sections: ‘exposition’ (setting the scene), ‘rising action’ (the plot builds and excitement increases), ‘climax’ (the turning point for the main character), ‘falling action’ (any remaining conflict unravels), and ‘denouement’ (concluding the story).

Although this analysis was limited to a specific type of drama, it clearly forms the basis of a broad range of literature. However, it would be difficult to construct a plot starting from those general observations. In order to find a more specific formula, it is necessary to examine a genre that is by its very nature formulaic. Such as James Bond, for instance.

The Italian novelist Umberto Eco once wrote a detailed analysis of Ian Fleming’s James Bond novels, in which he reduced the books down to nine different ‘moves’. Examples include ‘M moves and gives a task to Bond’, and ‘Villain tortures Bond (with or without Woman)’. Eco claimed that all of these moves are invariably featured in each book, although they may appear more than once and in different orders. According to him, Fleming is able to disguise these similarities by altering secondary elements such as locations and supporting characters, whilst leaving the basic framework untouched. This enables the reader to enjoy what is in many ways a new adventure, whilst still having the comfort of knowing more or less how the narrative will proceed.

Although it is important to stress that Fleming did not use this formula when plotting his novels, it does raise the interesting question that if he had deliberately constructed each of his plots from a recipe, could he ever have achieved such success? For that matter, could anyone?

To answer this, one need look no further than the novels of Lester Dent. Dent was a hugely successful American writer who had over 150 pulp fiction novels published during the early 20th century. Today, though, he is probably most famous for his ‘Master Plot Formula’. This is a set of instructions that he developed, which provide a step-by-step method for plotting a 6000 word pulp story. The formula describes precisely how to divide the story, and clearly lays out the narrative goals for each section. It is somewhat inflexible, but this may well be what lends it its reliability, with Dent himself saying, “No yarn of mine written to the formula has yet failed to sell”.

However, this recipe only applies to a very narrow genre, and Dent was the first to admit that producing high literature was not his main priority. The question still remains as to whether there is a universally applicable secret to the perfect plot.

Doesn’t that suggest that there really is no limit to the number of stories that can be told?

Over the years many people have tried to boil plot down to its most basic elements in attempts to answer such a question. Christopher Booker once argued that there are merely seven primary narrative structures from which almost all stories are derived. But the last word on this topic must go to William Wallace Cook, who in his 1928 book ‘Plotto’ set out to catalogue as many conflict scenarios as possible that could occur in a literary work. The result is an astounding collection of around 2000 unique plot ideas, each one cross-referenced with possibilities for how it may have arisen.

But it would seem that, rather than helping to uncover a secret formula for narrative, ‘Plotto’ might actually be doing the opposite. For if one man was able to devise such vast numbers of plots, doesn’t that suggest that there really is no limit to the number of stories that can be told? Of course it is possible to make general observations about structure, but there will always be exceptions to any rule that we try and impose on literature. And besides, as Umberto Eco pointed out, it is often the small details and variations in a plot that make it enjoyable, rather than its overall form.

So in the end, is it possible to define precisely what makes a good plot? Of course not. And if there ever comes a day when it is, then that will surely be the day that literature dies.

Illustration by Emma-Kate Prout