Hatfield fails to pass motion expunging blackface allegations

HCFS_cut

by Justin Villamil

A contentious debate in the Durham Students’ Union Assembly on Wednesday culminated in the voting down of a motion that claimed that no Hatfield students ‘blacked’ or ‘browned up’ during college fashion shows.

The debate was in reference to this year’s Hatfield College Charity Fashion Show (HCFS), which had the theme ‘Africa’ and the 2013 show, which had the theme ‘Bollywood’.

As the motion was voted down, this means that official Students’ Union policy says that the Hatfielders inappropriately ‘browned up’ for the show in 2013, an action  in violation of official SU policy.

The original motion condemning blackface was also tied to the HCFS. This new motion would have struck Hatfield’s involvement as an example from the record, and stated further that the Assembly believed that the fundraiser had raised a great deal of money for ‘work across the African continent’.

The motion was proposed by the Hatfield Senior Man and seconded by the Hatfield Senior Students’ Union Representative and was well-attended by approximately fifty Hatfielders, many who came following an e-mail from a JCR representative to students.

The ensuing debate was extremely heated, with several Hatfielders claiming that the previous motion condemning blackface had “victimised Hatfield.”

“[We had] zero complaints from attendees… [and] one complaint from a non-attendee,” one Hatfielder claimed in favour of the new motion.

The member of Hatfield further stated that the fundraiser had been extremely successful in raising a great deal of money for charity (about £5,000).

On the opposing side, a member of the Durham University Feminist Society (FemSoc), speaking against the motion and that money raised for charity excuses the theme, said that:

“Hezbollah raise quite a lot of money for the poor.”

Against the claim that tanning is used around the world simply to improve aesthetic, another student in opposition to the motion said:

“[You’re] trying to save your reputation at the expense of learning from it. The fashion show perpetuates the stereotype of the ‘African Continent’… [as] somewhere that needs your help.”

Hatfielders further claimed that the majority of the college supported fashion show wholeheartedly, and one Hatfield model suggested that there were personal attacks against the models in the show.

When the motion was voted down, nearly all the Hatfielders present left in protest while cheers were heard from the back of the room.

In an open letter of complaint to the Students’ Union President, one student, Robert Double, took issue with the procedure, saying that:

“My observations at the Assembly have very much tainted my view of Durham Students Union, and indeed to a certain degree, those who are supposedly running it on my behalf. I feel, first and foremost, let down.”

The Hatfield student claimed that debate on the floor was stifled when the Chair expedited the process and cut off further discussion.

Double also objected to Students’ Union officer David Morris’ comments.

Morris voiced concern about “immediately tweak[ing] a [standing order],” and further suggested that the debaters should “take [the] discussion elsewhere.”

“[Morris] was willing to look past factual inaccuracies which may be present in the motion, and wish to preserve it as it is, on the grounds that it hasn’t been in existence for a very long time,” said the student.

“It almost felt that he was implying the whole process of amendment was ‘too much work and hassle’ and we should just ‘leave it as it is for while’.”

Some, however, argue that these accusations are unfair. In a letter to the Students’ Union, Serge Chapman, Cuth’s JCR president wrote that:

“The key lesson to take away from [Mr Double’s complaint] is not how poorly the Union runs Assembly but how little students understand what the purpose of Assembly is and how students should best to handle accusations or complaints made against them.”

“Assembly is not a public court for passing judgement but a place where students can be united on certain issues and turn that feeling into action through policy.”

Chapman went on to say that he would have greater sympathy for those who felt their voices had not been heard in a more direct arena such as a private meeting with complainants or a meeting to discuss events or disciplinary actions.

“As it stands I think as much student voice was heard in the medium chosen to make it clear the arguments for both sides…” Chapman said.

In response to Double’s comments, David Morris told Palatinate:

“I believe that debating the same policy repeatedly whenever somebody is unhappy with the outcome can seriously undermine the democratic process.

“To have immediately revoked a section of democratically-agreed policy could have set a dangerous precedent. There was an opportunity to object to, or amend the original proposal before the Assembly meeting in March, but no such request was received.

“I am saddened by how this situation has progressed. I hope we can all learn from this experience.”

A spokesperson from Durham Students’ Union said:

“Durham Students’ Union is a democratic organisation which supports open and fair debate. The members of Assembly are elected from a wide base and they have the authority to approve policy on matters affecting students. In this case, there have been two debates (in March and May). Assembly has approved a policy which opposes ‘blackening up’ and also encourages event organisers to give due consideration to their fellow students and to avoid cultural stereotypes. We strive to achieve an inclusive culture at Durham University.”

Image Courtesy of: Hatfield College Charity Fashion Show 2014