Energising England World Cup squad highlights inadequacies of ‘B team’ proposal
Monday, May 11th 2014, heralded a new dawn for the England national football team as Roy Hodgson announced his 23 man squad for the World Cup in Brazil, with seven other hopefuls, eagerly awaiting a chance to represent their country, on the reserve list.
The air of positivity and excitement surrounding the squad announcement is largely a result of the astonishing breakthrough of young, skilful and talented English players in this season’s Barclays Premier League.
New stars such as Adam Lallana, Ross Barkley and Luke Shaw have enthused supporters across the country and will join experienced counterparts, such as Captain Steven Gerrard, Joe Hart and Wayne Rooney, on the plane to Brazil.
They will also be joined by promising talents who have set the Premier League alight this season. Raheem Sterling and Daniel Sturridge have made key contributions to Liverpool’s phenomenal title challenge, whilst Gary Cahill has been a rock at the heart of the meanest defence in the league at Stamford Bridge.
It is a squad full of potential and promise; however it does, in my opinion, contain several faux pas. Chris Smalling has had a mediocre season at Old Trafford, and is notable for a number of discernible weaknesses in his game, particularly marking at corners, and thus Curtis Davies of Hull would have been a fairer pick.
“the future seems promising for England with a promising array of young talents stepping into the main squad”
He has been key to Hull’s success this season and it is my view that players who have excelled at less fancied clubs should have as much recognition as those who play at bigger clubs. The only other alteration would be the inclusion of Gareth Barry in place of Frank Lampard.
Barry has had an extremely strong season at the heart of the impressive Everton midfield, allowing the likes of Ross Barkley to flourish. Lampard has had a mixed campaign, and is less impressive in the deeper role that both Barry and Gerrard have excelled in this season.
However, Barry has been the scapegoat for England since the debacle against Germany in the last World Cup, though that incident was the result of far more fundamental issues, such as the fact he was only half-fit and was asked to cover extremely quick Germany forwards, something that Lampard himself would struggle with.
Nonetheless the future seems promising for England with a promising array of young talents stepping into the main squad, and they will gain invaluable experience which could help them form the bed rock that will become the basis for a strong England team in years to come.
This makes the proposal for Premier League “B” Teams to enter a new League 3, in what will essentially be the fifth tier of English football, a puzzling affair.
Not only will it greatly disrupt the integrity of the Football League, with the potential in years to come for the 11th placed team in League 1 to be promoted to the Championship, there is also the fundamental question as to how this change will benefit young, English players.
The system works in Spain because it exists already as the structure; however it is not a system that has encouraged attendances. The Championship, the English 2nd tier, ranked as the 4th most attended league in the world in 2012, whilst the Liga Adelante, the Spanish 2nd division, ranked 16th, behind League 1, which is the English 3rd tier.
Ultimately the question will be asked of whether fans of resident football league clubs will want to attend when the quality of their league structure will be diluted by “B” teams with no core fan base or ambition to grow as their own entity.
Instead of this ill-thought out proposal, the FA and Premier League should continue to focus on initiatives that will encourage the improvement of youth facilities and coaching throughout the English football pyramid.
As Roy Hodgson has proved with his national squad selection today, if young, English players are good enough, they will be selected. The likes of Luke Shaw, Ross Barkley and Raheem Sterling did not need to play for a soulless “B” team in the 5th tier of English football.
Instead they benefitted from top quality coaching from their parent clubs, and earned their opportunity to play for their club, and now their country.
The 2014 England World Cup squad proves that the efforts made to improve youth coaching and facilities are beginning to bring positive results. This process should continue, and the ill-conceived “B” teams proposal should be consigned to the dustbin forever.
Photograph: commons.wikipedia

