Ethiopia-Egypt water issue: not quite so transparent
By Chris Caden
Of all the water on Earth, only 2.5% is freshwater available for human use – and of this, only 1% is easily accessible surface water. While this may suggest that water crises are set to become far more common, the UN estimated that only 60% of easily available water – from rivers, lakes and aquifers – was actually being used, showing there is more than enough water to go around.
Water will all always be a political issue on a range of scales, however intense geopolitical struggles like that of the Ethiopian Dam are far more reflective of poor water management frameworks, than of water availability.
The intense conflict over the Renaissance Dam has its roots in agreements made in 1929 and 1959.
Construction of Ethiopia’s ‘Renaissance Dam’ started in 2011, on the ‘Blue Nile’ – an area through which 85% of the Nile’s water flows. While the dam will not impact water volume itself, it will impact the rate of flow of the Nile through areas downstream – of note is Egypt which has its own dam: the Aswan High Dam.
The intense conflict over the Renaissance Dam has its roots in the 1929 and 1959 Nile Waters Agreements, which gave Egypt and Sudan, backed by colonial powers, de facto control over all the Nile’s water and a veto on projects built on the river. While of course the tension between Egypt and Ethiopia is rooted in water, it is exacerbated much more by Ethiopia’s rejection of the colonial framework mandated by the Nile Waters Agreements.
Compare the water tensions of Egypt and Ethiopia, with other places where countries must share their water. European laws and directives, for example, help to push member states into better managing their domestic water supplies. This is done through promoting water efficient technologies, fostering a water conserving culture, and improving drought risk management.
For European trans-boundary water concerns, the EU’s ‘Water Framework Directive’ mandates that water policy be coordinated in what it calls a “genuinely European approach” – along natural trans-boundary lines of the river, rather than action being taken on disjointed national levels.
Trans-boundary rivers, therefore, are managed between member and non-member states with ‘international river commissions,’ which involve all stakeholders and work towards common objectives like better water management, controlling flooding and tackling river pollution. Furthermore, disputes between member states can be referred to the European Court of Justice, ensuring that there is open dialogue between all stakeholders, and that the framework is fair to all.
Resolution is made much easier when open dialogue, with management frameworks fair to all stakeholders, is present.
Water management is never easy, and is political on a range of scales. Conflict isn’t just between international players, but is also found domestically within a country’s borders.
Proposed water transfer schemes in England and Wales, typically moving water from the water-rich North and West to the water deficient South have been met with hostility, with concerns ranging from cost, to environmental damages, to issues over water equality.
China’s South-North Water Transfer Project has already cost upwards of $80 billion and required the relocation of 330, 000 people. However, resolution is made much easier when open dialogue regarding water, with water management frameworks fair to all stakeholders, is present.
Between UN frameworks like the Water Courses Convention and the Global Water Partnership’s ‘Integrated Water Resource Management’, it may not be unlikely that, in the future, water conflicts like Ethiopia and Egypt are the exception, not the rule.
Image: The Nile at dusk via Creative Commons
