Parliamentary sovereignty: a force for good
By Chris Caden
Constitutionally, parliamentary sovereignty has never been absolute. Though limited, Parliament does have some hard constitutional restrictions to its sovereignty. No parliament can bind a successor; no parliament can extend its lifetime, and since the 1707 Treaty of Union, Parliament cannot abolish the separate legal systems of England and Scotland.
However, beyond these constitutional restrictions, parliament is supreme and can legally legislate on all matters, even when legislation appears to be ‘entrenched’. The argument that parliamentary sovereignty has been lost to the European Union, for example, has since been proven wrong as Parliament has exercised its sovereignty in deciding to leave — an option it always had. Yet, parliamentary sovereignty is not a blank check for the government of the day to do whatever it wants.
Abandoning the idea of parliamentary sovereignty would throw the political system into uncharted territory
Institutions like NATO and the EU which pools Parliament’s sovereignty, or Acts like the 1997 Human Rights Act which appear to constrain Parliament, are not entrenched as this would bind a successor, however they are protected by political mandates which cannot be simply overturned by governments on a whim. This is evidenced with the current pandemic – legally, Parliament was able to pass the Coronavirus Act (2020) whenever it pleased, but the otherwise unthinkable draconian restrictions have only been passed because politically it was accepted as permissible given the current crisis.
Once acknowledged that parliament is so heavily restricted by what is politically permissible, rather than legal restraints, it is clear that instead of questioning the legitimacy of the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy, we should instead ask what Parliament does and does not have a political mandate for, as this is the deciding factor in how both the Government and Parliament acts.
Parliamentary sovereignty is not something to treat with suspicion.
Indeed, perhaps more than just irrelevant, questioning the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty in a time of crisis may be actively irresponsible. Parliamentary sovereignty is the foundation of the constitution, and suggesting that during a crisis it can become null and void may be playing with fire. Abandoning the idea of parliamentary sovereignty would throw the political system into uncharted territory, as the UK’s political system is much more reliant on long standing conventions, understandings and legal judgements, rather than the clear rulebook as provided by a codified constitution like that of many other nations.
Take away the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty and the relationship between all branches of government change — a logical consequence of removing Parliament’s ability to legislate on all matters legally means, by definition, some actions parliament could take must be illegal, giving judges the power to strike down legislation they deem illegal. At best this leads to confusion during a crisis as to what parliament, the executive and the judiciary can legally do; at worst it leads to power politics between the branches as each seeks to maximise their share of political power in this new political system the UK would find itself in.
Parliamentary sovereignty is not something to treat with suspicion. Parliamentary sovereignty lies not with the government, where this plan for schools to reopen originates, keep in mind, nor with individual MPs, but instead with the institution of Parliament. This institution can no doubt be improved: a more proportional voting system to elect MPs and Lords reform such as removing hereditary peers are two obvious areas of improvement. However this institution should be trusted — between its select committees which interrogate the executive and receive expert advice to inform decisions to Parliament’s standing orders which have been used countless times for emergency debates to hold the government to account, this institution can be trusted — or at the very least can be trusted enough to delay a conversation of its sovereignty until after a crisis.
Image: DavidMartynHunt via Creative Commons
