How will Durham keep us safe this term?
By Claire Spirtas-Hurst
This autumn, Durham University has the opportunity to learn from the experiences of American universities. For example, the University of North Carolina’s Chapel Hill campus has closed, after a week of in-person undergraduate classes resulted in a 13.6% positive coronavirus test rate – up from 2.8% the week prior.
With our own university seemingly set on providing a mix of in-person and online instruction for Michaelmas term, we are likely to see a similar increase in cases if appropriate precautions are not taken. As part of a community that includes not only students, but also faculty, staff, and local residents, the University must establish clear policies that will protect everyone in Durham City. Because undergraduate classes at Durham do not start until mid-October, we have a unique advantage in being able to adopt the best features and avoid the worst mistakes of the American universities that are currently returning to campus.
It is unclear whether the University has a plan that will accomplish this goal. There are plenty of uncertainties surrounding the virus. Not all of these uncertainties are immediately obvious to us as students, but more communication about the decisions being made and why will help to allay concerns about how the University plans to handle our return to campus.
The University must be able to switch from a socially-distanced timetable to an all-online one.
First, the University must strike a careful balance in tone. We all know that this academic year will look and feel like no other. We know that it is disappointing that this year’s incoming students will not have the fresher’s experience that they have anticipated, and that foreign language students cannot go on their years abroad. We must manage our expectations about what this year’s university experience will look like. But also, the University must prepare us for these changes through communication that is open, frequent, and consistent.
The University should engage us students in an ongoing dialogue about the current state of coronavirus cases on campus and any plans for a scenario in which all in-person learning must cease.
Worryingly, the University has stated that “the mode of delivery may need to become fully online if the Government returns to stronger social distancing requirements”. This acquiescence to governmental guidelines fails to acknowledge the likelihood that the Durham University community – being both highly connected and populated by young adults who may or may not adhere to social distancing guidelines – will become an area where the infection rate is abnormally high.
The University must be able to switch from a socially-distanced timetable to an all-online one as soon as the case rate becomes unsustainable. Thus, the University must be aware of its own case rate, and changes to it, which can only be known through weekly testing of the entire University community.
The University has so far failed to communicate any of this to students. We have heard nothing about testing, guidelines to mitigate disease transmission outside of social distancing in the classroom, mask wearing, or contact tracing. The University needs to have a plan and needs to communicate that plan to its undergraduates.
If Durham adopts the same strategy, students who could otherwise infect everyone in their tutorial groups or seminars can be identified.
Fortunately, Durham can learn from the experiences of others. Cornell University is following guidelines suggested by data scientist Peter Frazier, under which the entire campus community will be tested once or twice a week. By doing this, Cornell will be aware of any outbreaks of coronavirus and can isolate all students who have been in contact with those that test positive, even if they are asymptomatic. If Durham adopts the same strategy, students who could otherwise infect everyone in their tutorial groups or seminars can be identified.
Another approach that could be considered is to mandate a two-week quarantine upon arrival in Durham City for all students, both domestic and international, as Middlebury College has done. During the week of the 10th to the 16th of August, Durham City and its surrounding neighbourhoods all recorded between zero and two positive coronavirus cases. Before an outbreak in Stanley earlier this week, Durham County as a whole recorded between two and three cases per 100,000 residents, which was well below the UK average of eight per 100,000. Undergraduates at Durham live all over the UK and all over the world – most international students will likely need to quarantine anyway, as a part of the Government’s strategy to reduce infection brought in from abroad. If domestic students are also told to quarantine, then we can try to reduce the level of virus brought from other locations before the term begins.
If domestic students are also told to quarantine, then we can try to reduce the level of virus brought from other locations before the term begins.
Of course, these measures would be an imperfect substitution for the safety provided by keeping all learning online. If the University commits to digital instruction for the entirety of Michaelmas term, as University College London has done, concerns about the accessibility of in-person, distanced, masked teaching for disabled, immunocompromised, or international students can be addressed more easily. If the University insists on providing some instruction in-person, then they must prove to us all that they have fully considered the implications of their decision and have mitigated as many risks as possible.
Finally, the University must provide adequate mental health support for all students, faculty, and staff. As the pandemic wears on, already extant mental health problems are worsened. Freshers, who may be living away from home and their regular support systems for the first time, are likely to be the most affected by isolation or anxiety. The University must create safe social events and opportunities that everyone can access.
As students, one thing that we can do to reassure the local community of our commitment to acting responsibly is by pledging to follow social distancing guidelines, wearing masks when we socialise with those outside of our households, and meeting outdoors when possible. By working with the University to strike a balance between safe learning and safe socialising, we can try to make the most of a new way of attending university.
Image: Keith Davenport via Flickr.
