Editorial: On the ropes
By Poppy Askham
As the end of Epiphany term creeps closer, Durham calendars are brimming with summatives, glitzy balls and a seemingly never-ending stream of charity fashion shows. But one date few students are likely to have circled in their diaries is Wednesday 2nd March, the day votes close for this year’s Durham Students’ Union (DSU) elections.
Crowned the UK’s most unpopular student union in the National Student Survey for two years in a row, DSU perennially struggles to attract both candidates and voters in its elections.
Turnout in elections has failed to climb above 20% for four years. Despite the irresistible promise of an audience with Jackie Weaver for the college with the highest number of voters last year, just 3207 students participated, 13.8% of those eligible.
For contrast, last week’s Aggression Sessions, Durham’s student-run charity fight-night, attracted 1,000 paying ring-side spectators and PalTV’s brilliant live stream of the event racked in more than 3,600 views.
At this point, DSU elections have descended into such a farce that a boxing match would arguably be just as fitting a way to ordain the next set of officers to preside over the great concrete monolith of Dunelm House.
Unfortunately for this flight of fancy, boxing matches, unlike SU elections, traditionally require more than one participant. Of six paid sabbatical roles up for grabs, three are uncontested, the second time this has been the case in two years.
The conclusion of the races for Undergraduate Academic Officer, Postgraduate Academic Officer and Welfare and Liberation Officer are foregone, as the only alternative, re-opening nominations, is essentially defunct.
Disregarding the stigma created by the controversy over the 2020 RON campaign, the new rules mean that should anyone attempt to encourage RON votes without registering themselves as a candidate the entire option would be disqualified and votes transferred.
Boxing matches, unlike SU elections, traditionally require more than one participant
All this is not to make a personal attack at any of this years’ candidates, nor at the current officers: certain right-wing publications have done more than enough of that in recent months. The problem is not down to individuals – the majority of those that run have a genuine altruistic desire to improve the experiences of their fellow students – it is institutional.
Within a collegiate system, the Students’ Union is inevitably less influential than in other universities. We also never see the behind-the-scenes work; most students’ primary interaction with the SU is through quickly binned emails, Freshers’ Fair, or negotiation with the many layers of bureaucracy involved with running a student group.
But even with those disclaimers in place, the upcoming elections are a sombre reflection of the DSU’s failure to break through to those it purports to represent. The disconnect between the Union and students cannot solely be chalked up to the University’s setup, and instead of addressing the issue DSU has sought to ignore or arguably to make it worse.
Following the RON saga, the DSU launched a ‘democracy review’, the findings of which were nothing short of damning. Just 4% of students were found to have greater loyalty to the Union than their colleges. In response, a referendum on a new democracy model was planned and then promptly scrapped.
Shortly afterwards yet another set of changes were put forward which, flying in the face of their own report, reduced college representation within the SU. Amidst backlash, these proposals were once again shelved, only to be resurrected in a confusingly worded manner just this term. And guess what? Once again the plans were thrown out.
Both the mind-boggling back and forths of the last two years and the depressing state of this year’s elections are clear indicators that the SU is achingly out of touch with students.
Of course, it is too early to say whether my cynicism is entirely merited. Perhaps the combination of recent national media attention on the Union and an unusually controversial candidate will be enough to entice students to the online voting form. But even if this is the case, urgent work needs to be done to repair the relationship between DSU and the student body.
Regrettably should the status quo persist, a students’ union that wins the attention, let alone approval, of the Durham student body seems about as plausible as the presidential wannabes donning silk shorts to square up to each other in the ring.
Illustration: Rosie Bromiley

