Durham University’s interim degree plans leave students in a state of limbo

By Daniel Hodgson, Emily Doughty and Ben Webb

Many third years at Durham University have been left feeling unsure of their post-Congregation future, as there is no guarantee that all finalists will graduate in the coming weeks.

An email sent to students recently revealed that all students will receive a results transcript on the week commencing 26th June 2023 containing any current marks. For continuing students, the University has said that no student will be unable to progress to the next year of their degree solely as a result of the Marking and Assessment Boycott.

Resit examinations will still take place in August 2023 for continuing students who have one or more module mark that is less than 40%. The resit timetable will be published on Thursday 20th July 2023.

If not all marks are available during the resit period, resits will be scheduled during the next academic year.

For finalists, a final degree classification will only be rewarded when all marks are available. If the student has at least 80 credits, they will be rewarded an interim classified degree. The class of an interim degree cannot decrease when it becomes a final degree classification, but may be upgraded.

Joe McGarry has spoken to Palatinate and expressed his surprise at “how slow the University worked to come up with a mitigation process and how late they left to start it”. In their communication to continuing students, the University said that “no-one will be prevented from progressing solely as a result of the marking and assessment boycott”.

Joe McGarry has expressed his surprise at “how slow the University worked to come up with a mitigation process and how late they left to start it”

Palatinate has spoken to students across multiple year groups about their fears regarding the marking boycott. A third year English student said “For this to happen to our specific cohort is frustrating…there is no consistency and it seems deeply unfair as some departments will be disadvantaged.”

The University said that they wished to communicate as much key information as possible, as soon as possible. For those who would have not reached the credit requirement many thought that the update added little for them. Caleb Tutt, a third year politics student at Collingwood, called the May update “somewhat useless”

An Archaeology student has expressed her concern to Palatinate in regards to the “higher-than-normal final average mark requirement for interim classifications” mentioned in an email sent in May to all finalist students. This higher than expected mark requirement may mean that they “only just miss out” on an application in the short term, and, if they achieve a better classification later on, this “will be too late” and they would’ve already lost out.

This student doesn’t “understand why the Uni has chosen this”, wondering why the University doesn’t instead “look at treating their staff better”

This student doesn’t “understand why the Uni has chosen this”, wondering why the University doesn’t instead “look at treating their staff better” – in allusion to the UCU demands. Matthew, a third year international student told Palatinate that the boycott had more impact on him as an international student because he was unable to take the bar exam in Singapore without a classified degree. He said as an international student he felt that he had it “tough” due to the impact of Covid and the impact the boycott could have on his friends getting visas.

Many students also believed the University should be doing more to organise, with a third year Philosophy student saying the University was “not cooperating with the lecturers and paying them a fair wage”. Another third year student who studies music said that Durham could be doing more, following the model of Cambridge University and urging the UCEA to negotiate in a public manner. They called it a “reflection of how much the uni cares about the staff” that they did not try and fix industrial relations “knowing full well the plan of strike action and boycott”.

Matthew also echoed this saying “Just pay the staff more. It really isn’t that difficult. If the Uni can charge crazy fees for both international and home students, and buy an overpriced new business school, they can definitely afford to pay the staff more. It’s either that or the management is just terrible”.

In his 12th June communication with students, Tony Fawcett reiterated that “This is a national dispute, involving 145 universities, and it is not in our power to resolve this at local level”. Some students are disappointed with the UCU and the actions that lecturers have taken.

A third year Classical Civilisation student at St. Chads College said: “I had compassion with the staff as when they did their strike they seemed like they really wanted to keep teaching us. But after this disruption they have proved they don’t care”

A third year Classical Civilisation student at St. Chads College said: “I had compassion with the staff as when they did their strike they seemed like they really wanted to keep teaching us. But after this disruption they have proved they don’t care.” The only finalist who Palatinate spoke to who was happy about the decision was a third year Geography student who said “I know that my grades aren’t that good but if I graduate with a transcript instead of grades, I can apply to grad schemes I’d think I normally wouldn’t be able to apply for. Maybe I’m subconsciously happy the inevitable is being delayed. It’s a bit weird, but whatever.”

Palatinate spoke exclusively to SU President Joe McGarry earlier this month. Mr. McGarry said how “There seems to be a general sense across universities that they were hoping the boycott would be resolved by UCU and it wouldn’t actually come to a head.” Most positive however, according to Mr. McGarry, is the no detriment policy brought in for the interim degrees. This means that any grades given to students can be increased but not decreased.

“All universities are judged on grade inflation” and this is something that is a “concern” of the University and Durham is particularly “concerned about their reputation (…) not just thinking about current students but the students applying in 10 years. To protect future students they were always going to be cautious about this.” The SU President argues that the no detriment policy is the “best way” for students to be protected from issues surrounding the interim classifications and the SU “is always aiming to fight for current members” so this is something they pushed.

Mr. McGarry believes that the reason for the marking and assessment boycott and further UCU industrial action is because the system of higher education is “a bad system” and a “broken” one

He also suggests that “it will be interesting to see how the marking and assessment boycott affects first and second year students as well” as the SU has received criticism from students asking “why they have been prioritising finalists”. Mr. McGarry believes that the reason for the marking and assessment boycott and further UCU industrial action is because the system of higher education is “a bad system” and a “broken” one, and “it is a shame that our students have become collateral in that”.

He said that the SU has been trying to encourage the Durham University Vice-Chancellor Karen O’Brien to “publicly encourage renegotiation” regarding the marking and assessment boycott but as of yet “she has failed to do so”. The SU President stated that the best way for students to aid the marking and assessment boycott’s removal and either the same for interim classifications or its greater success, is to write a formal complaint to the University and “do all we can” to get the University to push the case for re-opening negotiations.

On the marking and assessment boycott, Raj Jethwa, Chief Executive: of UCEA “HE institutions respect employees’ right to take lawful industrial action, but the marking and assessment boycott is a choice made by UCU and in turn by its individual members. Students have no such choice and that is why HE institutions with a duty to protect students will withhold pay for partial performance. It is wrong for UCU to encourage small numbers of its members to try to inflict damage on students in pursuit of a higher pay award that is simply unaffordable.”

Durham UCU told Palatinate that “UCEA are simply lying when they say the MAB is failing. Across multiple departments at Durham there is massive disruption. Many students do not have the grades to pass into subsequent years and for finalists there are multiple missing grades”

In response to these comments, Durham UCU told Palatinate that “UCEA are simply lying when they say the MAB is failing. Across multiple departments at Durham there is massive disruption. Many students do not have the grades to pass into subsequent years and for finalists there are multiple missing grades.

“They are also lying when they say “employers are at the table to negotiate”. What they mean is that they are willing to negotiate on Terms of Reference for further negotiations that members of UCU have rejected by 56% in an e-ballot of all UCU members nationwide.

“They are also not representative of all universities: Cambridge, Sussex, LSHTM, Queen’s University Belfast and the Senate of Aberdeen University have all voted for negotiations to restart without imposing preconditions of trying to negotiate on terms that have been rejected by UCU members as inadequate.

“At Durham management say that “dialogue” is key to resolving the dispute but they are currently refusing to sign a joint statement calling for negotiations to restart. They also talked about dissertation and other marking potentially continuing on into autumn with all the negative consequences. This approach only prolongs the disruption for students – the responsibility for the current impasse lies with senior management both nationally and locally.

If students want to hear Durham UCU’s side of what is happening and ask questions we are holding regular open meetings for students on zoom on Wednesdays at 1pm.”

The University emailed all students on Monday 19th June to update them on the situation.

Image: Daniel Hodgson