Durham University criticised for handling of Durham Union racism incident
By Emily Doughty
A Durham University student has criticised the University on social media for their handling of hate speech as the University vow to “learn” from the incident.
Samantha Smith, a second year Law student of Afro-Hispanic heritage was called a “dirty n*****” by a member of the Durham Union Society Equalities Committee last year. Ms Smith has said that she was the only woman of colour holding a position on the society committee at the time and said that the student “knew what he was saying and blatantly targeted me based on my race”.
In a Facebook post on the group “Overheard at Durham Uni” Ms Smith said she informed the University of the hate speech she had faced in the Durham Union when she was a member. An investigation was launched both by the University and the Durham Union.
“Some of the things he has said about me reduced me to tears and were beyond horrible to read”
Samantha Smith
The student who used hate speech was required to write an apology to Ms Smith. The student’s apology to Ms Smith read: “You will be aware that I am required to have no contact with you. I assure you that I will abide by this and this letter is written sincerely to offer an apology to you.
“I have been given this opportunity to write to you indirectly. I am therefore writing this letter offering my sincere apology to you as I understand my behaviour has caused you distress. During the last few months, I have reflected on my interactions with you, and it is my intention to follow the advice provided by the university.
“I wish you all the best in the future and once again I am sorry for the distress you have experienced.”
Ms Smith has criticised the apology, saying that “In his ‘apology’, he doesn’t even MENTION what he’s apologising for. He showed no remorse then and clearly still doesn’t now”.
She went on to say that during the investigation the student “denied everything” and accused her of “lying, insulted me and tried to degrade my character. Some of the things he has said about me reduced me to tears and were beyond horrible to read.”
This is despite the fact Ms Smith says she had “5+ witnesses, CCTV footage, and the dings of an internal Union investigation which all ruled in my favour”. Ms Smith also received an email from the University where they admitted that the apology was “minimal” and that in the future they would make provisions so a “reasonable standard of apology” was met.
“Durham is supposedly one of the top academic institutions in the world, yet they fail to tackle even the most clear-cut racist incident… an apology and no-contact order isn’t sufficient”
Samantha Smith
In the Facebook post she also criticised the Universities handling of the case saying that “Durham labelled it as a “Level 1” offence (aka. Lower level) – in what world is calling someone a dirty n not serious??” She went on to say that “Durham is supposedly one of the top academic institutions in the world, yet they fail to tackle even the most clear-cut racist incident… an apology and no-contact order isn’t sufficient. They claim a zero- tolerance racism policy, yet clearly don’t take it seriously”.
In a statement a Durham University spokesperson said, “We are deeply sorry that one of our students has experienced abuse.
“We do not tolerate racism in any form and entirely condemn language of this kind.
“These allegations have been investigated by both Durham University and the Durham Union Society. Sanctions have been imposed in line with university policies and processes which go much further than those disclosed on social media.
“We do not tolerate racism in any form and entirely condemn language of this kind”
Durham University
“We are concerned that the apology was not commensurate with the very serious nature of the offence. We will learn from this.”
Image: Uli Harder

