“Why are we being punished?”: MLAC fourth years denounce exam proposals
By Emily Doughty
Modern Languages and Cultures (MLAC) finalists could be set to face in-person exams for the first time in their university careers, after the department revealed plans for exams in languages classified as “hard” and “super hard” to be taken fully in-person.
The proposals would mean that exams in “easy” languages including French, Italian and Spanish would continue to be conducted online this year, while exams for languages including Arabic, Chinese, Russian and Japanese would be done in-person.
These plans were modified when it was announced by the department on Wednesday (23rd November) that oral and aural (listening) exams for finalists would be in person, but all written examinations would take place online in a 24-hour window.
In further communications with Palatinate the University said the decision was based on the “rationale behind this is based on a careful balance between maximising the validity and reliability of the assessments, whilst at the same time considering the final year students’ learning experiences”.
They went on to cite the impacts of distance learning and the virtual year abroad as key reasons behind the decision.
Many students were left angered over the original proposals, with many of them saying that the original proposal was “outright damaging”. Another student said: “The University/department cannot justify this unfair treatment as having the students’ best interests at heart.”
For many finalists, these assessments would be the first time they sit an in-person exam since their A-levels. One finalist told Palatinate: “We haven’t sat timed exams since A-levels, and to put this stress on us on top of already having to do our finals is grossly unfair.”
Another student said the plans would “impact our degrees badly,” following “2.5 years of online classes which are obviously of inferior quality to physical classes.”
Many students questioned why those who had only done exams online through their time at university should now be made to do them in-person for the first time this year. One summed up their feelings by saying that “the most important year of our degree” was put at risk “when the University decides to make the first in-person exams that some of us have done in 4-5 years.”
“The University/department cannot justify this unfair treatment as having the student’s best interests at heart”
This anger left many students feeling “punished” for doing harder languages, with one finalist calling the decision “discriminatory” against these harder subjects. One student said that “the discrimination against the harder and non-European langauges is disgraceful. Students of harder subjects should not be punished in this way.”
Some students have also claimed that conversations had taken place between students and senior figures from the MLAC department prior to the move online due to Covid-19. Students say these conversations indicated to them that these subjects were moving towards online exams long-term, meaning the plans for in-person assessments were a surprise to them.
This anger was furthered by the fact that many students had not been encouraged to keep up with their written language skills during this time, with one finalist telling Palatinate that they were now having to relearn their chosen language on top of all their other third year commitments.
Furthermore, an open letter to the MLAC department written by a Japanese Language finalist said that “a handwritten exam would not allow us to demonstrate our ability to recognise Kanji, the sole form of Kanji we were taught and assessed in for the past 3 years.” They went on to say that “our lack of Kanji writing ability is of no fault of our own.”
Students were also left frustrated as many who take “hard” and “super hard” languages were more likely to have faced disruption in their year abroad, with many students in these languages not being able to go abroad at all due to various travel restrictions.
One finalist called the decision “discriminatory” against the harder subjects
One Japanese student told Palatinate that the lack of a year abroad had affected their language skills, with the student questioning how the MLAC department could see their language skills on par with students from previous years: “How can we be expected to be at the same level of performance as though we had gone to Japan?”
A Russian language student said that “my language skills are definitely not up to par with people who managed to go to Russia before the ongoing war; the difference between peers who didn’t manage to go and people who did manage to go and people who did manage to go is incredibly vast”. They went on to say that the department was se!ing them up “to fail.”
Another student claimed that there was “such (a) disparity in the levels of writing” between those who went on their year abroad and those who did not, while another student placed their source of anxiety on the MLAC department, who had “continually stressed the year abroad as the most important year for learning the language” and as such, the student felt disadvantaged without it.
After the proposals were released, a Japanese language finalist conducted a survey which found that, out of the 79% of Japanese studies finalists who responded to the survey, 100% disagreed with the current exam proposal.
The impact of the announcement has also impacted the mental health of students, with one student telling Palatinate that they have seen a “significant deterioration of mental health” among their friends, with several students speaking to them saying they “wanted to drop out” from their course.
there has been a “significant deterioration of mental health” among friends
MLAC students have said that the department’s decision was justified in a zoom call, where staff explained that there was suspected cheating among students during online exams, while the written components for the “easy” languages being “easier and therefore unlikely to cheat”.
However many students have also criticised the department‘s categorisation of languages, with one student saying: “In what way could a language, a living piece of culture, be compared objectively and put into levels of difficulty.” In a separate open le!er to the MLAC department, one student said the decision was an “unsavoury implication” and was built on a “bizarre pa!ern of logic.”
Others have questioned the justification that the MLAC department could not detect cheating in harder exams, with one student questioning how “experts in the language would not be able to detect cheating?”
In a statement to Palatinate, Professor David Cowling, Head of the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University, said: “We take student welfare and well-being very seriously and we fully understand the concerns of students, particularly when their studies have been disrupted by external factors such as the Covid-19 pandemic.
“It is important to say that no final decision about end of year language exams has been taken. All cultural modules are being examined online.
“It is important to say that no final decision about end of year language exams has been taken”
“We have been involved in a thorough and constructive, ongoing consultation process with students, staff and senior members of the School. We have also taken into account the views of external examiners who provide a quality assurance overview of our exam process.
“As a result, a proposal will be put forward by the School to a panel of senior University academic staff, which also includes student representation.
“That panel will take a final decision on the format of end of year language exams in due course. Ultimately, assessments are designed to test the learning outcomes of modules, which must be considered alongside student preference.
“We are also mindful that some students suffered disruption to their year abroad due to external factors and are concerned about the effect this might have had on the development of their language skills.
“We have processes in place to mitigate the effect this disruption might have on our students’ learning, and detailed information about this will be shared with students as soon as possible. We would ask any students with concerns to speak to the School or their College support network who will be happy to help them.”
Image: Amana Moore

