Durham Books Festival 2022: Who are we now?

By Holly Downes

In Who are we now?, Jason Cowley, the editor of the left-leaning newspaper, New Statesman, asks the question we all collectively seek – who are we as a country? What truly defines Englishness in its purest form? Whilst in one corner is the country that wishes to conserve their identity of the English tradition, the other is one of diversity and inclusivity that fosters in large cities and among the younger population. And in the middle is the group who are nervous of such dramatic change, but nevertheless, are willing to accept this change because without change, our identity will remain stagnant.

The question for progressiveness is one that dwells on the mind of Cowley, whose sole mission is to discover a fixed definition of Englishness that is both modern yet conserves our history. His book especially stresses the complex, ever-changing nature of our nation and aims to show what it truly means to be English amid the constant turmoil our country seems to find itself in. Through analysing key news stories over the past 20 years, from Gillian Duffy challenging Gordon Brown during the 2010 election to the terrorist attack in Finsbury Park Mosque in 2017, he investigates how these events have changed England as a country – for the better or for the worse.

Through analysing key news stories over the past 20 years … he investigates how these events have changed England as a country – for the better or for the worse

Starting with the product of post-1945 utopianism, namely the creation of new towns and cities which offered a new life after the war, he focuses on his birthplace – Harlow, Essex. With the government funding all the facilities built here – from the library to the leisure centre – he stresses that although it supplied hope, it felt like a ‘social-democratic experiment’ which was inevitably going to fail. Claiming that there was ‘no funds for maintenance’, he shows how society’s attempt to create a utopia came crashing down when the country was not in a financially secure place to maintain such utopian visions. It became a time of deprivation rather than innovation and success.

Yet, this is just one of many of England’s identity. We are not just a country of run-town cities that once supplied hope, but through the many key stories explained by Cowley, are constantly grappling with social cohesion, belonging, and identity. These stories, one of my favourites being the humorous exchange between Gillian Duffy’s and how it reshaped British politics, all interconnects in the book – an interconnection that shows that our country cannot be marked by division, but by cohesion. 

From Brexit to the coronavirus pandemic that truly exposed the cracks in our government, my national identity is one of instability

Of particular focus in Cowley’s talk for the Durham Books Festival last weekend, where he was accompanied by Alex Niven, an English Literature professor for Newcastle University, was the topic of the hopelessness among the younger generations and how such attitude is changing England’s identity once again. Being part of the ‘Gen Z’, my teenage years have been accompanied by political turmoil. From Brexit to the coronavirus pandemic that truly exposed the cracks in our government, my national identity is one of instability. With my generation possibly never being able to get onto the housing ladder, both figures argued that economic empowerment is necessary to seek newness and optimism about the future. Our country needs to create the sense that we will all get jobs, that we will not all be in debt, and that we will own a house. Yet, this hopeful image is one that seems a distant dream for people my age.  

All in all, Cowley’s book is cleverly articulated, well-researched, and leaves readers somewhat confident about the constant shifts England encounters by the second (lets thank Liz Truss for that one).

Image: Hanna Katrina Jedrosz via Birmingham Literature Festival

https://www.dunelm.org.uk/donations/palatinate