The contradictory censorship of humanities courses
By Holly Downes
With The Times recently undertaking an audit of university reading lists, where they published an article titled ‘Censorship on Campus: universities scrap ‘challenging’ books to protect students‘, they revealed that over 1,000 trigger warnings have been applied to books and, in some cases, books have been completely removed from modules. Works that contain an array of triggering topics, from slavery and suicide to sexuality and child abuse, have been wiped from teaching to protect the wellbeing of students who actually decide to read the set module texts.
But this calls for a deeper question, one that is becoming increasingly prevalent as our generation is becoming more ‘woke’ — is our intellectual growth being impeded because we are all a little too sensitive? With The Times revealing that Shakespeare’s infamous play, Romeo and Juliet, was given a content warning for ‘containing inter-familial violence, forced marriage, murder, and suicide’ and, therefore, became an optional text; this decision seems a little extreme over matters that serve as a lesson of the cultural norms in the fourteenth century. Allowing students to stay sheltered from topics that educate and enlighten seems to remove the whole reason why we choose to study and secure a degree — to learn and grow, not to remain intellectually stagnant.
There is no doubt that our generation has become too sensitive. There seems to be a never-ending debate on whether we are all too sensitive or just more informed, and, whilst I agree that we have become more politically and socially active than older generations, many seem to get triggered over the tiniest things. With ‘cancel culture’ becoming the norm for celebrities over genuine mistakes, renowned novels that form the foundation of humanities courses have become a victim of this same toxic culture. The censorship of literature is a scary concept that only dystopian novels discuss, yet it is becoming a reality.
Students will miss a huge chunk of learning needed to excel in their studies
Although Durham University was never mentioned in the investigation, perhaps pointing towards its successful decolonisation of curriculums, many other universities were accused of completely wiping off award-winning works that have made my love for literature grow further. From Essex University ‘permanently removing’ the 2017 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, The Underground Railroad by Colson Whitehead, due to concerns of graphic descriptions of slavery; to Aberdeen University withdrawing the classic play, Miss Julie by August Strindberg, due to discussions of suicide. These classics are arguably the foundation of English Literature degrees. Without learning the classic novels, that have allowed these degrees to even exist, students will miss a huge chunk of learning needed to excel in their studies.
Whilst I appreciate that warnings are needed for certain books that discuss objectively triggering topics that could affect readers, completely removing them from curriculums and preventing others from reading and learning about such topics appears rather contradictory. Considering the global push for the decolonisation of curriculums, where many universities are aiming to diversify reading lists by including works written by minority authors, scrapping books that include detailed accounts of slavery, racism, and abuse because it can be triggering for readers seems rather counterproductive. How can one push for diversity in curriculums yet remove the books that make such curriculums diverse?
Instead, providing a trigger warning on books that contain topics that could harm is an approach I advocate for. While taking the Postcolonial World Literature module in my second year, which includes works mentioning every harmful topic possible, every lecture started with a trigger warning. Every lecturer warned the very few of us who showed up to lectures that the topics discussed could be upsetting, so those who knew they might be affected could leave. But these books were never completely scrapped; otherwise the module would never exist. Rather, it gave us exposure to works that educated us on the cruelty of slavery, rather than keeping us in the dark.
We all have the freedom to expose ourselves to new literature, and university curriculum decisions should never strip us of that right. In the end, how can we ever academically excel without reading novels intended to enlighten and teach us to strive for change?
Image credit: AhmadArdity via Pixabay

