Durham University Chamber Choir: a star performance
By Patrick Brennan
It would be an easy mistake to assume that Durham University Chamber Choir – whose reputation as Durham’s finest choral ensemble is firmly cemented into the student psyche – attains its excellence simply because it gets all the best singers. Friday’s ‘Star of Gold’ performance, however, firmly proved that DUCC’s standard is far greater than the sum of its parts.
Performed in the sublime acoustics of Hild Bede College’s Bede Chapel, the ensemble took us on a plaintive, reflective and stunningly beautiful tour of the season’s sacred side, providing a strong selection of both early music and eerie 19th/20th century pieces. Conductor Thomas Brooke, already a seasoned veteran of Durham’s choral circuit, quickly asserted his affinity for the task at hand, and scrupulous levels of eye contact between choir and conductor made for an exquisitely together-sounding start in the opening Renaissance piece.
The first half of the concert revolved mainly around Josef Rheinberger’s Mass in Eb major, whose five sections were broken up by variety of early 20th century pieces. Despite the hundreds of years’ difference, the programme was well thought out, as the pieces were similar enough to retain a costant mood, but adequately different so as to showcase the choir’s masterful use of dynamics – something that is challenging to boast using early music alone.
The inclusion of a rather excitable piece by Peter Warlock towards the end of the first half was perhaps something of a wild card, although a second Warlock piece – the beautiful ‘Bethlehem Down’ – was a perfect opening to the second. Other highlights included plentiful amounts of choral staple Herbert Howells, a surprisingly restrained number by Gustav Holst and, my personal favourite, a reimagining of the traditional ‘Coventry Carol’ by contemporary composer Philip Stopford.
From the performers themselves, particular highlights included Claire Ward’s hauntingly perfect solo during a specially commissioned arrangement of ‘Silent Night’, and the solid benchmark soprano vocals from Emer Acton and Rowena Ashby, who often appeared to be the glue of the entire choir. However, this was not a night of showing off or isolating individuals: it was the squeaky-clean togetherness of the group that shone through more than any solo or particularly loud choir member, and for this a special mention must be made, again, of conductor Thomas Brooke.
Indeed, in such an exposed environment of unaccompanied singing, where so many things could go wrong so easily, the only major error that recurred was that of pitch: several potential slip-ups were deftly saved by the ensemble as a whole, but on a couple of occasions the piece veered down into flat territory, with no accompanying organ to help lift it back up. It appears that even Durham’s finest are not immune to a cappella singing’s most menacing trap.
Ending the concert with a second Renaissance piece seemed to me to be a disappointing choice of closing number, as such a similar piece had been used to start. This choice became more understandable when the choir surprised us with an encore performance of ‘Once in Royal David’s City’. But alas, even with the gorgeous harmonies and childlike purity of Fiona Brindle’s opening solo, this was a misfire, as the choir weren’t given a chance to either go out with a bang, or leave us drenched in the passion of some of the former pieces; instead the mood was somewhat cast aside in favour of a gimmick, which had the unfortunate side effect of chopping the choir’s well-deserved and rapturous applause cleanly in two. Whether or not this style of ending will become a trademark of Brooke’s conducting era remains to be seen…
This was, however, undoubtedly one of the best Christmas concerts I have attended in my time at Durham. It must also be mentioned that the choir were fantastic hosts, putting as much passion into their serving of (free!) mince pies and mulled wine during the interval as went into their performance. I look forward to attending their future concerts, when the discipline, teamwork and attentiveness that were so obvious in this performance can provide solid foundations for something truly spectacular.
Photograph: Durham University Chamber Choir
