Durham Student banned from free speech debate

By Alex Leggatt

Bristol Free Speech Society claims Durham student, Angelos Sofocleous, has been banned from partaking in a panel debate on free speech at the University of Bristol.

The University of Bristol Free Speech Society, the group hosting the debate, released a statement on Saturday, stating: “due to Student Union bureaucracy we have been forced to cancel the invitation we extended to Angelos Sofocleous to be on our panel discussion on free speech.”

Mr. Sofocleous, a postgraduate student studying Philosophy, was banned by Bristol Student’s Union, citing “security concerns.” The debate, which will ask the question: ‘Is there a problem with free speech on campus?,’ is due to take place on Wednesday.

Bristol Students’ Union has since contacted Palatinate to say: “The Freedom of Speech Society was informed of this one week prior to the event with the recommendation that the event is rearranged in order to allow security measures to be put in place and the event to go ahead.”

Speaking to Palatinate, The University of Bristol Free Speech Society said: “Two weeks after notifying the SU of his participation and one week before the event is scheduled to take place the SU informed us that in order to hold the event as scheduled we must disinvite him as a panellist. The justification given is that his presence on campus constitutes a ‘high risk’. The University Security Services informed us that they were not at all consulted by the SU on the matter.

“We have been working on this event for several months and we are severely disappointed by this last minute decision despite following SU policy to the letter. We feel let down by the unnecessary bureaucracy of the SU and their disregard for Free Speech.

“As the Joint Human Rights Commission outlined in their report last year, excessive bureaucracy is a prime reason for limitations of Free Speech on campus and we feel that this is a perfect example. We wonder why Angelos, who lives his life as a student on a university campus, would constitute a ‘high risk panelist’ and we have not been given a specific reason why the SU thinks this is the case.”

Tweeting about the decision to de-platform him, Mr. Sofocleous said:

https://twitter.com/Sofocleous_A/status/1094631348650823682

https://twitter.com/Sofocleous_A/status/1094631481773830147

He also offered his “full support to the University of Bristol Free Speech society” and “encourage[d] everyone to attend” the panel discussion. He has also written about his de-platforming in The Spectator.

In a statement to Palatinate, Mr Sofocleous said: “The practices of Universities and Student Unions to ban speakers are a worrying sign of the increasing influence of social justice orthodoxy in academia.

“Dangerous ideas, or what one would call hate speech, are, indeed, viruses. However, banning or censoring these ideas, or attempting to isolate them, does not help in exterminating them. The beauty of free speech is allowing ridiculous or hateful ideas to be expressed in society, and then witness them being defeated publicly.

“There is no reason that security should be a thing to worry about. The reason being that there is no violence in words – things cannot get violent at a debate if physical violence is not used.

“This need, in particular, highlights the hypersensitivity that exists in campuses […] I would say it’s a blessing if the environment you are in, especially a University, challenges your views and makes you feel ideologically uncomfortable.”

Mr Sofocleous provoked controversy last year when he wrote in a tweet: “RT [retweet] if women don’t have penises,” which led to him being fired from his position as assistant editor of Durham’s Philosophy Society journal, Critique and his position at The Bubble.

The president of the Philosophy society stated in an email to Mr Sofocleous that his comments served to “belittle trans experiences,” while leaving “no room for or to promote any fair discussions.” An apology was later issued from the Chief Executive of Durham Students’ Union after he filed a formal complaint to Durham’s Students’ Union regarding his ‘unfair treatment.’ His dismissal was deemed to be ‘procedurally incorrect,’ ‘unfair and undemocratic.’

Bristol University Students’ Union told Palatinate: “Bristol SU has not refused Angelos Sofocleous as a speaker. Bristol SU is committed to freedom of speech and the rights of all our students to discuss difficult and sensitive topics. 

 “Bristol SU and the University of Bristol have a joint external speakers procedure, which applies to all bookings and events. Bristol SU made an initial assessment of the speaker and recommended that security would be needed to ensure this event could run safely and smoothly.”

Photograph: Angelos Sofocleous via Facebook