‘A millstone around one’s neck’: Religion’s pernicious role in sexual health

By Harry Brierley

Recent guidance from the Faculty of Sexual and Reproductive Healthcare has advised that the seven-day break often recommended when taking certain variations of the contraceptive pill carries no specific health benefits. Thankfully, women can now ignore a ridiculous ‘natural’ process introduced half a century ago, which the scientist John Rock apparently believed would help appease the Catholic church.

Thankfully, women can now ignore a ridiculous ‘natural’ process introduced half a century ago in order to appease the poisonous Catholic Church.

The news is just one illustration of the deeply problematic role religion continues to play in determining sexual health and contraceptive practices. Around the world, including in supposedly secular societies such as our own, the laity – especially women – are too often subjugated by clerics holding a claim to legislate on matters of sex. Any sway they hold is already too much, and we continue to award unwarranted respect to such malevolent institutions at our own peril.

Sexual health, “a state of physical, mental and social well-being in relation to sexuality”, requiring “a positive and respectful approach to sexuality and sexual relationships, as well as the possibility of having pleasurable and safe sexual experiences, free of coercion, discrimination and violence” , continues to be envenomed by religious dictum worldwide.

Imagine the devastation caused when such vacuous rhetoric reaches, and continues to reach, the most vulnerable

In 2003, the Vatican’s president of the Pontifical Council for the Family, Cardinal Alfonso Lopez de Trujillo, warned that condoms are knowingly produced with small holes through which the HIV virus can pass. A year later, the auxiliary bishop of Rio de Janeiro, Rafael Llano Cifuentes, explained the Church was opposed to condom usage on the grounds of it being unnatural; understandably so, given he had “never seen a little dog using a condom during sexual intercourse with another dog”.

Imagine the devastation caused when such vacuous rhetoric reaches, and continues to reach, the most vulnerable. Clerical refusal to issue condoms, alongside the proclamation from leading religious figures that condoms are the cause of virus spread, means that the contracting of AIDS in Africa prevails.

AIDS patients can be refused treatment by hospital workers in Iran, where an HIV-positive worker can also be fired. In Pakistan, those with judicial powers can sentence a woman to be gang-raped in order to offset the shame of her brother’s crime. Throughout the Middle East – and in other Muslim-majority countries – the Koran is deemed enough to prevent pre-marital sex and prostitution. Yet, practiced in Twelver Shia Islam, “pleasure marriage(s)” (Nikah mut’ah) allow for temporary wedding certificates to be issued until business is conducted. Almost akin to prostitution, the women involved are left to suffer and die in silence having been infected by their once husbands. Hardly a respectful approach to sexual relationships free of coercion and violence, one could say.

The West, suffering from twisted Orientalist hypocrisy, is too quick to draw attention to such moral failures in the East. Hasidic fundamentalists continue to allow the practice of peri’ah metsitsah, whereby a mohel – a chosen circumciser and foreskin remover – circumcises a baby boy before sucking the foreskin away with their mouths. In the United States in 2005, this practice custom was allowed to continue so as to not violate the free exercise of religion, even after a fifty-seven year old mohel had given several boys genital herpes, and caused the death of at least two. 

So long as the United Kingdom remains theocratic, one cannot expect substantial change from the disastrous views on sex and contraception that perpetuate the Church.

In Britain, a third of state schools still divide communities according to religious belief, meaning the taxpayer continues to sponsor the dissemination of any of the above bunkum. And when LGBT equality and challenges to homophobia are promoted, like recently at Parkfield Community School in Saltley, it is met with protest from those enveloped by toxic scripture. In fact, so long as the United Kingdom remains influenced by non-secular policy, one cannot expect substantial change from the disastrous views on sex and contraception that perpetuate the Church. It must not be forgotten that same-sex marriage only became legal in 2014, illustrating how much work must be done before we’ve attained a positive approach to sexuality for all.

Communities around the world remain defined by those who wish to replicate nature, to which we continue to devote gratuitous respect. In the words of Christopher Hitchens, “we keep on being told that religion, whatever its imperfections, at least instills morality. On every side, there is conclusive evidence that the contrary is the case, and that faith causes people to be more mean, more selfish, and perhaps above all, more stupid.”

Image via Pixabay