DU Conservative and Unionist Association criticised for ‘Secret Motions’
By Hugh Ludford and Finn Watton
Durham University Conservative and Unionist Association (DUCUA) hosted a number of ‘Secret Motions’ at Port and Policy Nights last term. Attendees of these nights have told Palatinate that some of these Secret Motions have been “disgustingly sexist” and “blatantly Islamophobic”.
These Secret Motions were a feature of DUCUA’s ‘Port and Policy’ nights throughout Michaelmas 2025 and were publicised on the society’s Instagram using black redacted text, alongside their regular motions.
Secret Motions had been used in the past, but their increased frequency this year led a student source to tell Palatinate that their “regular utilisation” is “not traditional”.
One such Secret Motion was held in November 2025 following the election of Zohran Mamdani as Mayor of New York. Palatinate has heard that one member of the DUCUA exec introduced the motion “This House Believes Zohran Mamdani’s election is the Third Tower” while doing an impression of President Trump.
The wording of this motion likened the Muslim Mayor’s election to Islamist terrorism on September 11th and its effects on New York City. Palatinate was told by sources at the event that six to eight of the attendees left following this motion’s announcement.
Text messages seen by Palatinate suggest that other members would have left were it not for social ties to members who remained. Testimony of sources suggests that concerns around how the exec would perceive their leaving contributed to some attendees staying after this motion.
Messages seen by Palatinate also suggest that people who left during this debate were mocked, and support testimony saying some people were left feeling “ostracised from the society”.
The first source mentioned in this article described the motion as “blatantly Islamophobic” and “racist”, and questioned whether the exec “like it when people are upset and [the secret motions are] controversial”.
Referring specifically to the Mayor Mamdani debate, this attendee reflected that “it’s a little bit disturbing that after they did a Secret Motion where people got really upset and… left that they have now decided that [Secret Motions are] something they want to do”.
These Secret Motions were a feature of DUCUA’s ‘Port and Policy’ nights throughout Michaelmas 2025 and were publicised on the society’s Instagram using black redacted text, alongside their regular motions
Another motion that sparked controversy last term related to adult film star Bonnie Blue. This motion was not secret: it was publicised in full on the society’s Instagram account, and was the first Port and Policy of the academic year. The motion was titled “This House Would sleep with Bonnie Blue”.
This motion was criticised at the time as “weird and misogynistic” by the Chair of Durham Young Greens. One attendee said that the motion, and the tone surrounding its discussion, was “atrociously sexist”.
This attendee reported to Palatinate that one exec member described Bonnie Blue as an “ugly bitch”. Another student who is a DUCUA member said comments about the adult performer being “low-hanging fruit” [to sleep with] have been circulated by some society members as a running joke.
Responding to these claims, a DUCUA spokesperson said, “We strongly deny these allegations. Such language, both inflammatory and unparliamentary, is never tolerated by our members nor the exec. If statements like this do slip past, we welcome attendees to discuss concerns with us [the exec] or with the SU.”
One attendee said that the motion, and the tone surrounding its discussion, was “atrociously sexist”
In a similar vein, Palatinate understands that a very similar motion was debated last academic year, under a different executive committee, about another adult film star, Lily Phillips. This motion was held in secret but was not publicised.
Another Secret Motion that took place in Michaelmas 2025 was titled “This House Would record Trump blowing Bubba”, referring to an email released from The Epstein Files around that time. Part of the debate allegedly revolved around whether ‘Bubba’ referred to former US President Bill Clinton or a horse on Little Saint James Island of the same name.
This student source attended the debate and told Palatinate that “[t]he society during its debate did not take into consideration the hurt felt by the Epstein victims themselves” and that other students present at the debate raised concerns that more pressing issues deserved the attention of the society.
This DUCUA member told Palatinate that the society is “a haven for elitism” and “does not express the modern nature of the Conservative Party”.
Routine, publicised Secret Motions began in the new academic year, and three were publicised on DUCUA’s Instagram account through Michaelmas term. Palatinate understands these motions were written in advance, often by members of the executive.
This Epiphany term, DUCUA have not hosted any Secret Motions.
Responding to this article, one exec member emphasised that the claims made do not apply to the whole society.
This Epiphany term, DUCUA have not hosted any Secret Motions
A spokesperson for DUCUA told Palatinate, “We regret to hear the hurt we have caused to certain attendees of our events. It was never our intention for our motions to cause distress. It is precisely because we oppose prejudice and hatred that we have held these difficult motions. We firmly believe that true change does not come from walking away from tough discussions, hiding behind anonymity or flashy punchlines. Instead, change comes from having open and frank debate, where hateful beliefs and opinions can be rigorously scrutinised and rejected.
“Our intention with the secret motions was always for problematic beliefs and narratives to be challenged through satire. For example, the Mamdani debate was intended to mock Trumpian fearmongering, paralleling rhetoric all too common in the US. Our fear was that having these openly on our Instagram would mislead people into believing they are official society positions, which they certainly are not. On the contrary, every mentioned motion was overwhelmingly defeated.
“We clearly failed to properly signpost our honest intentions, and some members have gone away with an inaccurate impression of our society, issues we hope to rectify with SU support. We deny the representation of our society as unwelcoming or elitist as it is simply untrue. We believe our majority POC, majority state-school educated, majority LGBT+ exec, is proof the wider society is welcoming and accepting. Instead of judging our society on a handful of quotes by nameless sources, we welcome Palatinate and its readers [to] judge our society for what they see themselves.”
We clearly failed to properly signpost our honest intentions, and some members have gone away with an inaccurate impression of our society
Gareth Hughes, Chief Executive of Durham Students’ Union (SU) has said “The Conservatives’ commitment to be an inclusive and educational political society has been undermined by their poor choices, reported by Palatinate.
“I have been very clear with them that they must not repeat their mistakes. I take them at their word that they are sorry, and will change their approach, and the Durham SU team will work closely with the society’s leaders to support them in this work.”
Image: Amana Moore

