Dame Sarah Mullally and the impossible balancing act
By Nina White
On the 28th of January, former Bishop of London, Dame Sarah Mullally, was officially confirmed as the new Archbishop of Canterbury. As the first woman to get the role, this is huge news; but to what extent might Mullally truly impact the politics of the Church of England (CofE)?
The appointment follows the resignation of St John’s College Durham alumnus, Justin Welby, after accusations that he did not take sufficient steps to bring a child abuser associated with the CofE to justice in 2013. The prestigious post is the highest position within the CofE except for the figurehead of the monarch, standing as primus inter pares (first among equals) among all Anglican archbishops, and usually holding the post for 10-15 years.
So how could this new appointment affect the politics of the Church? It is not unfair to say that the CofE, like many religious institutions, has a history of structural patriarchy. Women have only been allowed to be priests in the CofE since 1993, and bishops since 2014, whilst the post of Archbishop of Canterbury, the CofE’s ‘spiritual leader’, has never before been a woman. Moreover, as recently as 2018, just 30% of active CofE clergy were women. Although this figure is slowly becoming more balanced, Mullally herself admits that she has “experienced misogyny” in both her secular and Church roles, and has said it’s “important” for her to use her newfound platform to speak up about sexism in the Church and society at large. Many have therefore celebrated her appointment as a step in the right direction for greater equality within the Church.
Mullally herself admits that she has “experienced misogyny” in both her secular and Church roles
Yet as head of an institution with a history of decidedly conservative social stances, we might be justified in questioning the extent to which Mullally may choose or be able to impact this culture. In recent years especially, the Church has seemed to find it difficult to stay up to date with social progress whilst keeping hold of its traditional values and ideas. As such, due to their immense global platform within the CofE community, the Archbishop of Canterbury has tended to remain relatively equivocal on pressing political topics. For example, former Archbishop Justin Welby said in a 2017 interview that he “c[ould]n’t give a straight answer” to the question of whether gay sex is sinful, claiming that he “d[id]n’t do blanket condemnation.” At the time Welby said, “I don’t think it is sinful to say that you disagree with gay sex”, yet also claimed that homophobic hatred was sinful. This contradictory stance, despite same-sex marriage being legalised in the UK 4 years prior, is characteristic of the side-stepping which high-profile clergy are accustomed to doing around potentially controversial topics within this traditional institution.
Play[ing] to both progressive and conservative members of the CofE, show[s] that Mullally is not immune from the Church’s … broad political spectrum of followers
Mullally has been more definitively progressive on some fronts, including on issues relating to gender and sexuality, but has also demonstrated reluctance to more extensive legal measures in these areas. For example, the Archbishop has spoken on being “pro-choice” regarding abortion, but in June 2025 opposed an amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill which fully decriminalised abortions in England and Wales. Mullally also brought forward a motion to offer blessings for same-sex couples which was approved by the CofE in 2023, but also said the measure “does not go nearly far enough for many but too far for others.” These equivocal, somewhat contradictory responses, which try to play to both progressive and conservative members of the CofE, show that Mullally is not immune from the Church’s ongoing struggle to juggle its broad political spectrum of followers.
Ultimately, in accordance with tradition, the vast majority of clerical work is not overtly political. For example, in Mullally’s recent New Year’s message as Bishop of London, she used the opportunity to raise awareness of those suffering from poor health, and encourage communities to support them. Whilst this is no doubt a great reminder of kindness and community, the speech stayed clear of directly political discourse.
In an age where religion is on the decline, it is possible to overstate the significance of the Church on society and politics. However, for the roughly 40% of people in England and Wales who still identify as Christian, whether they regard Mullally’s views as either too progressive or not progressive enough, this appointment is hugely significant.
Mullally’s hope is to contribute to “an environment where all people can flourish and which is safer for all,” but in a society so increasingly divided between conservatives and liberals, whether she will be able to strike a balance to satisfy all groups remains doubtful.
Image: Roger Harris via Wikimedia Commons

