Complicated love in Sally Rooney’s ‘Intermezzo’

By Nina White

Sally Rooney has become one of our generation’s widely-loved romance and literary fiction writers, with bestsellers like Conversations with Friends, Beautiful World, Where Are You?, and, of course, Normal People which became a hit TV show starring Paul Mescal and Daisy Edgar-Jones during the 2020 lockdown. The Irish author is known for her imperfect, realistic, modern love stories, but her latest 2024 novel Intermezzo takes this to a new depth with a freshly insightful view far more complicated than a star-crossed lovers romance.

Intermezzo primarily follows two brothers in Dublin, Peter and Ivan, whose father has recently passed away, as they each navigate their personal lives in the wake of loss. The brothers have a 10-year age gap which, alongside the shadow of their parents’ divorce when Ivan was young, created an uncomfortable distance between them. Yet we follow each brother’s perspective through a kind of fluid free indirect discourse, with a third person voice giving us insight into the psychology of each in turn, sometimes to the point where the perspectives change abruptly from one paragraph to the next without warning. As readers, we’re forced to interpret the shift between protagonists using context alone, which creates a certain kind of affinity for the brothers’ brotherly love – or lack thereof – which is at the very heart of this novel, which might at first glance appear to be a romance.

They both care deeply about each other and are ingrained in each other’s lives, and yet we’re unsure whether to categorise Sylvia as a love interest or platonic character

On the one hand, 32-year-old lawyer Peter pursues the much younger, attractive Naomi, who relies on him for money, gifts, and eventually even housing. The pair’s passionate yet somewhat casual affair blurs the lines between lust and love, with career-man Peter unable to decide whether he truly cares for this unlikely partner, a beautiful, devil-may-care, directionless young woman. At the same time there is Sylvia, Peter’s ex-girlfriend whom he seemed set to marry until she broke off the relationship following an unnamed accident that happened before the narrative. They both care deeply about each other and are ingrained in each other’s lives, and yet we’re unsure whether to categorise Sylvia as a love interest or platonic character in relation to our protagonist, Peter. Just like itmoften happens in real life, it’s not easy to define the blurred line between friendship and romance; just when we think a clear boundary has been set one way or another, it is inevitably crossed.

On the other hand, we have 22-year-old chess prodigy Ivan, the awkward kid coming into his own as a man, who finds himself stumbling into an unlikely whirlwind romance with Margaret, a venue manager 14 years older than him. Ivan’s voice is intensely self-conscious, particularly at the start of the novel when he struggles to comprehend that a woman like Margaret is paying him attention:

“Well, I’m definitely a lot more awkward than you are, he replies. You know, when you’re talking, everything you say sounds so normal and like, smooth. I can never get words to come out that smoothly.”

The hazy boundaries between love and lust, friendship and romance, brotherly affection and hatred, are ever-shifting

Their relationship asks the question: can people with such vastly different life experiences truly be in love? Margaret has experienced loss of her own, being stuck in a marriage to a husband with a severe and destructive drinking problem, and she herself is grappling with feelings of inadequacy and uncertainty. Can love transcend these feelings, or are Ivan and Margaret just an example of people coming together out of a need to escape solitude? These questions linger unanswered over the novel, but in my opinion Rooney leaves us feeling that love, in any form, is preferable to having none at all.

Ultimately, it’s not until the brothers reconcile that they truly come to terms with each of their experiences of romantic love. For Ivan, Peter’s apparent hypocrisy and lack of approval of his relationship with Margaret leaves the younger brother embittered, whilst for Peter, the knowledge that he has driven away his own brother, one of the few people with whom he should share an unconditional love, is just another factor which leads him further down a destructive path of substance abuse, poisoning his romantic relationships. The brothers’ reconciliation at the end seems to open up new and hopeful possibilities for each of them emotionally; it’s not until this fraternal love is realised that the road to pure romantic love seems truly possible.

In Rooney’s trademark style, this is a novel suffused with ambiguity. The hazy boundaries between love and lust, friendship and romance, brotherly affection and hatred, are ever-shifting, leaving us as readers to make up our own minds as to what is right and wrong in a world where love, in all its many forms, is never straightforward.

Image credit: Financial Times