Don’t make art a scapegoat
The University’s questionable decision to invest in £1.4 million worth of art as part of the £60 million Gateway Programme has become a scapegoat for a host of wider issues including the condition of the DSU and Elvet Riverside buildings, as well as the remuneration of hundreds of University employees.
However, developing an awe-inspiring collection of iconic artwork, restoring University facilities, and addressing wage issues don’t have to be mutually exclusive. This is not how University spending is managed. They are separate matters, each subject to separate streams of funding.
Ultimately, the real spanner in the works is the University’s seeming indifference faced with the dilapidated state of buildings like the DSU and Elvet Riverside.
What’s more, an abundance of misleading facts and figures have been stirred around, muddying the water.
John McDade of the Unison Union was appalled that the University would spend this much on artwork while keeping 555 staff on a rate of pay which is less than the Living Wage of £7.45 an hour. And yet the University has claimed that once overtime and other supplements are taken into account, the salary of its lowest-paid staff equals a sum above the Living Wage.
In any case, this issue of fair payment has a direct impact on the lives of hundreds of people so deserves gravitas and in-depth investigation, rather than being thrown in at the last minute as an accessory to the bandwagon argument that the University has gone on an irresponsible spending spree.
Not to mention that a considerable proportion of the art in the collection was actually donated to the University, which is something press coverage has overlooked somewhat. Notably, Fay Pomerance’s Sphere of Redemption on display in the reception of the Palatine Centre was donated to the University following the death of the artist, along with the four panels belonging to the Theme, on the understanding that it would be accessible to both staff and visitors.
Finally, it is misleading to maintain, as DSU President Archie Dallas does, that the university has ‘blown’ money on the artwork; the capital hasn’t vaporized, it has simply taken on a new form which will continue to increase in value. No wonder others consider the move a savvy investment, given the low pressure which is rife in the current economic climate.
£1.4 million may sound like a lot of money but, when placed in context, it constitutes just one quarter of one per cent of the University’s turnover for the two years in which the sum was spent.
If the melodramatic media coverage on the scandal has had any positive impact, it is in raising the profile of issues which affect students and employees of the university alike.
So let’s persevere in tenaciously tackling these separate issues, defending our position openly and honestly by paying attention to the facts, even after this sensationalism has dissipated.
Photograph: Lucy Edwardes Jones

