University spending on art is a worrying budgetary decision

Palatine-Centre-

by Alex Slotwinski

The revelation that the university has recently spent £1.4million on art to adorn the walls of the new Palatine Centre has been deemed “disgraceful”, but also forms part of a worrying series of budget decisions that suggest little concern for the interests of both students and non-managerial staff.

Firstly, it is curious that the university feels the need to spend money on enhancing its artistic prestige when it is one of very few institutions worldwide that boasts a UNESCO World Heritage site within its estate. Cliched though it may sound, Durham is a beautiful city which tourists flock to for its unique cultural heritage and buildings such as the Norman castle or world-renowned cathedral, whilst the smaller treasures within are also stunning examples of artwork.

Any examination of the university’s artistic assets must also include the artefacts within the Oriental Museum. Despite featuring relatively rarely on the tourist trail, the museum holds an extensive collection of Chinese and Egyptian artefacts.

Old buildings understandably require maintenance, but their preservation is an investment which is far more relevant to Durham than the purchase of works by Picasso or Warhol which, whilst exceptional in themselves, have no link to the University nor the North-East. Moreover, the beauty of the university’s existent artistic heritage is that it is freely accessible, to both students and the public.

Castle college students dine in a medieval great hall, matriculation and graduation ceremonies take place in the finest complete example of Romanesque architecture in Europe, and art history students can examine the Oriental Museum’s treasures first-hand as part of their courses. They are not hidden and confined to the managerial quarters of a building which is far less visited by students than the seemingly ‘forgotten’ Elvet Riverside.

In more general terms however, it is outrageous for the university to allocate such a large budget to artworks, whilst neglecting essential expenditure that would improve the experience of a much larger number of students and staff.

Unfortunately this seems to form just one component of a developing pattern of irresponsible spending, focusing on the indulgences and comfort of the top management whilst neglecting the people who play an equal role in making the university ‘work’: students, and college/housekeeping staff. Whilst the Vice-Chancellor enjoys a £21,000 salary increase, one in eight university staff are paid below the Living Wage of £7.20 per hour.

According to the university  “adopting the Living Wage is simply not sustainable in the medium term.” Yet neither is spending £1.4million to decorate one building when a central lecture facility, Elvet Riverside, is being left to fall into disrepair. Staff and students already had a taster during Michaelmas term of the extensive consequences of neglecting the maintenance of just this one building.

Spending money on the arts, whilst worthwhile and beneficial, cannot be justified as forming such a large part of the University’s budget during a recession, especially when there are other areas crying out for investment and repair.

The university should focus more on practicality rather than pride when planning its annual budget – especially if, in the long-term, it would like to maintain the quality and number of applications and high levels of student satisfaction. Is this consequence a bit far-fetched? Not really; whilst Durham’s reputation will ensure its popularity to some extent amongst applicants, the fact that the introduction of £9000 tuition fees has turned the university system into a marketplace cannot be ignored.

When having to pay this sum of money for fees, student may opt for a university with a better overall “package”, one with a reputation of investing in the experience of its students across the board, rather than maintaining luxurious managerial quarters. There are institutions which are competitive with Durham academically that may offer lower priced but higher quality accommodation than that of the college system.

The university’s investment seems to be focused upon the experience of consumers rather than that of students. Durham is sending mixed messages to many of us.

Photograph: Rose Innes