Legal aid cuts are a step too far
That the present government has a vendetta against society’s poorest and most vulnerable has been made abundantly clear. Caps on housing benefits and the imposition of a ‘bedroom tax’ are just a few examples of measures taken in the interest of cutting the deficit. In the context of recession, the political line may be that ‘we are all in this together’ as ‘there is no alternative’ to cuts in public services: yet it is not coincidental that society’s poorest demographic continues to suffer most.
Unlike those only marginally more affluent, the most vulnerable lack effective political representation meaning they are least able to challenge cuts targeted against them. This is compounded by the prevailing sense, in the current climate, that the less you have, the less you ought to have. And it is precisely in this spirit that the Ministry of Justice’s projected legal aid cuts are being pursued.
Article 6 of the Human Rights Act enshrines the right to a fair trial and effective representation, upheld by the provision of legal aid for those unable to cover such expenses, including legal advice, mediation and court representation in criminal, housing, debt and family problems. Civil rights group Liberty estimates that each year over two million people receive some kind of legal aid, explaining the international standing of Britain’s judicial system.
Yet it seems the government’s plans in ‘Transforming Legal Aid’, in the apparent interests of creating a ‘credible and efficient system’, threaten to jeopardise this reputation. With the single-minded aim of cutting £220m from the £2.1bn legal aid system, debate about projected reforms centres on the areas of provision, eligibility and payment.
Defendants will no longer have the right to choose their legal representative as legal aid contracts will be awarded on the basis of ‘price competitive tendering’ (i.e. who’s cheapest) with the ultimate aim of reducing the number of providers from 1,600 to 400. As the Bar Council has identified not only does this threaten the livelihood of smaller solicitors’ firms (where annual salaries are estimated to be around £25,000), it also projects the commercial dominance of interested providers such as Tesco and G4s.
Prospects of legal remuneration look bleaker still as lawyers will be paid a flat-fee per case taken on, regardless of whether the client pleads guilty (a shorter and cheaper trial) or not guilty (more usually longer and more expensive). As such, combining this with the necessity of competitive pricing as a precursor to awarding contracts, defendants are likely to come under pressure to plead guilty in the context of a clear financial incentive, as the Bar Standards Board has warned.
Further, only those who can prove they have resided in the UK for the last twelve months will be entitled to legal aid providing obvious legal obstacles to those whose resident status remains unclear while specialist firms providing representation for ex-servicemen and women will be threatened by monopolised giants. In sum, it is clear that the integrity of legal representation for society’s poorest and most vulnerable is in the process of being absolutely undermined, a sense strengthened by the overwhelming opposition the government faces from the Bar Council.
However, beyond these practical absurdities, morally repugnant logic underpins our government’s attitude to the poor. It seems that legal aid clients are presumed ultimately guilty, both of their own poverty and of finding themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time. Further, the same ideas run throughout welfare cuts, namely that the poor are responsible for their misfortunes and will pay with their homes and their dignity.
Discursively, we may all be ‘in this together’ but it is amongst the poorest, the disabled and the immigrant communities that our political elite, extending to the mainstream left which fails to offer a political voice of opposition, continues to find anonymous masses to blame and punish in the face of an economic crisis of an elite creation.
Yet Churchill, Thatcher and other giants on the right once claimed that the moral dignity of society lies not in the dizzying heights of potential affluence possible in economic upturns, rather in how those at the bottom of society are treated. And when we use those terms it is clear that we have much to be ashamed of.

