Does Labour have a women problem?

By Maria Hunt

The 2024 election saw an unprecedented number of female MPs entering parliament – 263 in total and 186 female MPs for the Labour Party. However, a change of face has not translated to a change of culture. Calls from Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, to ‘take action’ against misogyny in Westminster echoes other Women MP’s concerns over the ‘Boys Club’ culture in Number 10, both in the Labour Party and Whitehall more broadly.

Nandy condemned the anonymous briefings aimed at women which she described as ‘dripping with misogyny’. However, Nandy affirms that Starmer takes women MPs’ concerns ‘seriously’. Asserting her confidence in the PM, in an already hectic week, she ensures her comments are not levied solely at Starmer, but an institutional culture more broadly.

Yet, some personal responsibility can be placed on Starmer – not for creating but perpetuating a culture excluding women. Such as his decision not to make Lucy Powell Deputy Prime Minister, following the resignation of Angela Rayner.

The decision was most likely ideological, with Powell aligning to the Soft Left faction of the party, which was, at the time, seen to be the gateway to a leadership bid from Andy Burnham. Starmer made the choice to appoint David Lammy in an incredibly visible role that could have and previously has been given to a woman.

Harriet Harman is urging the government to bring back the role of First Secretary of State.  She encourages the role, which was last given in a Labour Government to the disgraced Peter Mandelson, to be given to a woman. Harman hopes this will ‘transform the political culture in government around women and girls’ – changing the customs in Westminster from the top down.

Harman hopes this will ‘transform the political culture in government around women and girls’ – changing the customs in Westminster from the top down

Laura Kuenssberg reports how a former Labour minister believes the culture is not purposely exclusionary to women – but that Starmer ‘has had to rely very heavily on the ‘boys network’ that he has.

Until the latest release of the Epstein Files, which truly revealed the closeness of Mandelson with the sex trafficker, Jeffrey Epstein, it was Morgan McSweeney who was the Prime Minister’s Chief of Staff. McSweeney was crucial to both Starmer’s rise to the Leader of the Opposition, to Prime Minister and is integral his ideology.

As his closest aide, Starmer heavily trusted McSweeney’s advice and judgement. Although not purposefully, Starmer in his advisors, alienated half the population. He has relied too heavily on a close inner circle dominated by men. Once more, not creating the ‘Boys Club’ culture, but perpetuating it.

In McSweeney’s resignation he admits his role in the decision to appoint Peter Mandelson as UK Ambassador to the USA: ‘I advised the prime minister to make that appointment, and I take full responsibility for that advice.’

A former Labour minister believes the culture is not purposely exclusionary to women – but that Starmer ‘has had to rely very heavily on the ‘boys network’ that he has

His iron grip over the party’s direction has gone, creates a new opportunity for Starmer’s inner circle.

Vidhya Alakeson and Jill Cuthbertson have replaced McSweeney as acting Chief of Staff. Appointing these two women demonstrates a conscious effort by the Prime Minister to reject these claims of misogyny within the Parliamentary Labour Party. Many hope that having women fill this role, becoming Starmer’s senior advisors, the so-called ‘Westminster bubble’ can be popped, paving away for a shift in culture.

Allegations of a culture of misogyny and ‘Boys Club’ remain prevalent in discussions around Number 10. The combination of Harman’s proposed female First Secretary of State and the appointment of Alakeson and Cuthbertson presents a shift in leadership and those closest to the Prime Minister. Some argue this is too little to change systematic misogyny within Whitehall. Whereas supporters of Starmer see that change as a positive, not just in the culture in the Parliamentary Labour Party, but around Westminster overall.

Image: A1Cafel via Wikimedia Commons