Grok, AI and “free speech” – Starmer vs Musk
By Maria Hunt
CONTENT WARNING: This article contains mentions of sexual violence.
Elon Musk’s platform, X, has come under pressure from the British government over its ‘AI assistant’, Grok, for its generation of sexual images. Before the crackdown, users of X could reply to a tweet asking: ‘@grok put this person in a bikini’ and it would do so. This AI can freely generate non-consensual pornographic images, used for harassment, humiliation and blackmail. Women and children have been targeted in particular. However, as social media companies maintain that they are not publishers, they cannot be held accountable for the content produced on their platform. They are not liable for what their users post, causing difficulty in legislating against harmful and illegal content. It is worth noting that other AIs have stricter policies to prevent this. Yet Grok is programmed to act with “maximum freedom”. But what does Starmer’s recent challenge to Musk say about free speech and his government’s stance on Trump’s administration?
The platform was ordered by the British government to suppress the creation of non-consensual images. In response, X made the image creation feature only available for those paying for X Premium. This change did nothing to address these issues; it simply put a paywall on the abuse. The Prime Minister’s spokesperson said this decision was “insulting the victims of misogyny and sexual violence” and claimed harsher punishments, including a nationwide ban of the social media site, could be imposed if no suitable changes were made.
Starmer has taken decisive action to protect women and children
The government sees these challenges to X as necessary to their manifesto promise to start ‘tackling violence against women and girls’. As Liz Kendall, Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, said in a statement to the House of Commons, “No woman or child should live in fear of having their image sexually manipulated by technology.” In her statement, she declared the creation of “non-consensual intimate deepfakes” as a criminal offence – bringing the Online Safety Act into full force.
Moreover, on the same day, Ofcom – the UK’s independent regulator for communications – launched a formal investigation into Grok’s sexual image generation. In conjunction with Kendall’s statement, Ofcom now has more legislative powers. Their enforcement powers can permit fines of up to £18 million against X, or in the “most serious cases” a court-imposed order “to withdraw their services from a platform, or requiring internet service providers to block access to a site in the UK.” In the meantime, X has suspended the image creation feature on Grok, preventing it from “allowing the editing of images of real people in revealing clothing”, an announcement from them read.
The Government’s action is almost universally seen as an incredibly popular policy, with YouGov polling revealing that 96% of Britons believe AI should not be allowed to generate sexually explicit content of real adults non-consensually. However, many see this as a surprising move from Starmer, who is directly challenging one of –if not the most– powerful men on the planet.
This is particularly interesting given Musk’s links to the Trump administration. Since their falling out in June 2025, over the One Big Beautiful Bill and subsequent attacks on X and Truth Social, the pair have reunited. Musk has been seen with Pete Hegseth (Secretary of War) and other members of Trump’s cabinet. And, solidifying their relationship, the owner of X has also been at a dinner with the President in early January at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate. The two powerhouses are back as friends again.
This makes Starmer’s crackdown the more interesting as his diplomacy with Trump has been him trying not to upset the United States’ President. The Prime Minister believes this strategy protects the US-UK ‘special relationship’, particularly in relation to the tariffs and attempting to influence his foreign policy. Here, Starmer has taken decisive action to protect women and girls, perhaps at the expense of their seemingly compatible relationship.
The government’s decisive crackdown on this has many people arguing that this is a guise for limiting freedom of speech. Seen particularly with those dissatisfied with the British government, with one X user from the account @TheHughAnthony claiming, “Starmer is trying to shut down free speech […] This is because he doesn’t want us saying the truth to the masses.”
Many see X as a haven for free thought, able to share and debate their views, particularly in a social media landscape that some see as having restricted free speech. Musk, himself, claimed he bought the platform to ‘try to help humanity’, yet he also said that X “cannot become a free-for-all hellscape where anything can be said with no consequences!”’ The latter aspect has lapsed in the minds of many. Free speech is the ability to speak without censorship. Free speech does not mean to be free of consequences.
Starmer is not trying to suppress free speech but rather carve out the consequences and stand up to powerful figures in the new, evolving and unregulated social media landscape. The limit Grok adapted is to prevent the generation of sexualised images, not to suppress discussion or debate. It is to protect women and children in the often-lawless land of social media. Starmer is surprisingly taking decisive action against one of the most powerful men in the world, who is so closely allied to the Trump administration, revealing how the new innovative AI can open new and dangerous forms of exploitation.
Image: Heisenberg media via Wikimedia Commons

