Does Durham need to put a stop to online learning?
By Isabelle Adams and Gray Burr
Isabelle Adams on why contact hours should be conducted in person
The recent release of teaching timetables for the 2022-23 academic year has revealed that the University intend to continue with a combination of in-person and online learning. Given that distance learning via online lectures and seminars was initially introduced to mitigate the spread of Covid, ‘blended’ learning serves as an unpleasant reminder of the lingering impact of the pandemic in all of our lives.
Whether implemented to protect the health of students and staff, or perhaps to fulfil the more practical function of allowing the University to overcome lecture theatre capacity limits, stretched by the increased intake of students in 2020 and in 2021, online learning is an inadequate response. I am lucky enough to have experienced university pre-pandemic—Covid struck in the second term of my first year at Durham—and I felt the sense of community fostered by face-to-face teaching dissipate as learning moved online, as I am sure did all students. Pre-recorded or live-streamed contact hours are no substitute for the real thing; no matter how convenient, online lectures will never rebuild the sense of belonging that we lost when we passively accepted this new method of learning, never before relied upon and still somewhat experimental.
As the discussion about the efficacy of online learning persists, I am reminded of a similar debate from a few years ago, following the decision of the University’s English Department not to make lecture recordings available via Panopto. Though other academic departments had already committed to recording and uploading lectures in order to better facilitate students’ accessibility needs in 2018, English opted out, fearing that attendance levels might drop, and that allowing online, remote access to lectures might bring about ‘material and undesirable changes in the teaching relationship’. Lecturers maintained that online and face-to-face lectures were incomparable; in-person attendance was strongly advised, if not mandatory.
We must expect the same high standard of teaching that Durham students received before the pandemic
Isabelle Adams
In the past, even when distance learning was implemented, it was always intended as a supplement to—never a replacement for—in-person contact hours, and provided primarily for students with disabilities. Now the University seem to have changed their perspective, but as students, we have all witnessed first-hand how online content has reshaped our relationship with teaching and learning. We should not embrace a method of teaching that was previously considered insufficient—that is, until it presented itself as an undeniably convenient solution to overcrowded lecture theatres, timetable clashes, and any other administrative challenges. Equally, we must not adjust our expectations, but rather expect the same high standard of teaching that Durham students received before the pandemic—especially when the University have offered no reduction in tuition fees, and attending university is more expensive than ever as a result of rising living costs.
Gray Burr on why the university is justified in implementing online learning
The university’s choice to keep some lectures online remains consistent with the decision last year to keep many exams online. Technology in our era has allowed for more hybrid learning which, while slightly altering the format of lectures, will not altogether change how we receive knowledge. Lectures are often spent listening to a professor speak for the duration of the period, whereupon we all leave with little to no questions for the professor. What changes when that moves to Zoom? We let YouTubers talk at us for an hour all the time and there are no shortage of opportunities to ask questions. After all, we have Microsoft Teams, office hours, and the Billy B at our disposal.
Digital lectures mean no daily commute. Students spend a lot of time running up and down cardiac hill. Since the addition of Encore lecture replays on Backboard – and “the hangover”’s lack of evolution – I have known a number of peers to forgo attending lectures altogether. While moving away from lectures in person for some courses removes the option to physically attend the lecture, it equally removes the embarrassment of groggy-eyed note-taking. When it comes to pre-filmed lectures released online, I have had professors choose to make the lecture longer or shorter based on how much content we have to cover. In a digital setting, professors have more flexibility to do the same because they are not pressured to leave the lecture hall at a specific time. Taking an extra ten to twenty minutes to address a question without hogging precious space may be the way forward, as joining and leaving Zooms is almost always discreet.
Hopefully, online lectures are a transitory measure while the university builds the necessary facilities to hold bigger lectures in person
Gray Burr
Then, there is the question of space issues in the university proper. Durham University is undeniably experiencing growth pains. With a huge expansion planned in the next decade, leading to generally larger cohort sizes, the university must commit to maintaining the quality of education despite space constraints, which I believe Zoom largely achieves. Hopefully, online lectures are a transitory measure while the university builds the necessary facilities to hold bigger lectures in person.
As the university moves towards being more technologically savvy (Two-Factor Authentication anyone?), more of these cockamamie but coherent solutions to growth pains are going to pop up. The justification for this measure is not pandemic-related increased intake, but long term sustained growth as a strain on spaces in Durham.
Image credits: Chris Montgomery via Unsplash

