Fantasy Football: An inherently neoliberal project?
By Louis Gregory
If, like me, you are religiously fanatic about Fantasy Football; if you seek its solace during insomniac nights and long library sessions, you have likely thought no further than the game itself.
It occurred to me one night that — whilst tossing and turning over whether to bring in Kane over Haaland — that fantasy football perhaps reflects — and possibly perpetuates — the governing logic of contemporary neoliberalism.
“What are you on about? That’s rubbish!”, you may reply. “You’ve got too much free time”, you may continue.
Whilst I would accept the latter claim — I definitely do — I would certainly rebuke the former.
For even at its most sparkling, purest moments of human elation, football is lost without its social expression. For fans on the terraces, it is not Fantasy Football that matters, but those moments of crushing loss, ephemeral solidarity and childlike hope that epitomise their experience.
Why is it then that we communicate our love for the sport — something defined intrinsically by an emotional, sometimes artistic experience — via a detached and ‘objective’ means?
The game’s neoliberal script essentially positions the manager as a high priest of financial doping: a £100m budget is to be spent in the most effective manner on the most effective players.
Managers become ‘experts’, who ‘study’ their players’ upcoming fixtures, adapting them to outperform fellow competitors. No longer are football matches merely remarkable spectacles in and of themselves but take on a new form as objects of study.
For even at its most sparkling, purest moments of human elation, football is lost without its social expression
In any case, the manager ‘alienates’ — and is ‘alienated’ from — football’s a wider social experience. One cannot field a team of players from their favourite team. Worse still, one is often forced to support players they may despise, from clubs they abhor. This neoliberal technocracy is devastating in its impact: efficiency is fetishised, and the sociality of football is kicked into the abyss.
Fantasy football’s genesis in England is an interesting case in point. The games’ arrival in the early 1990s was coterminous with a wider ‘neoliberalisation’ of the global economy.
Fantasy football was thus conceived in a historical moment characterised by unfettered hyper-privatisation, deregulation of markets, financialisation and attacks on social solidarity under Margaret Thatcher.
The Premier League, established in 1992 as a highly-sanitised, commodifiable ‘neoliberal’ version of football emerged to directly challenge the crowd disorder of the previous decade and to appeal to a new consumer base: the middle classes. Now, ‘clubs’, once the bedrock of local communities, have morphed into soulless nightmares and corporations.
With the ‘Super League’ controversy — an attempted coup led by Europe’s richest clubs to ‘breakaway’ from their traditional domestic leagues — still fresh in memory, football fans must consider what is to be done.
Few would deny that football is being snatched from the hands of its custodians. Meanwhile, we stare dead-eyed into the void of a silly little game. How we think about football is immensely important. We need to ask ourselves what it should do, who are its greatest beneficiaries, and what its future looks like.
I suggest that Fantasy Football, most likely subconsciously, affirms a governing logic that has corrupted modern football. I am not calling for a revolutionary overthrow of Fantasy Football. What its game’s managers must consider, however, is what is important: football’s technocratic, gentrified analysis or its ability to ignite passion, remedy suffering and inspire hope. Like your fantasy football team, this is your choice.
Image: Ben Sutherland via Flickr

