‘Mini budget’ explained: borrowing is no longer fun sized

By Hannah Redman

Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng’s budget last week, variously termed a ‘fiscal event’ or a ‘mini budget’ by news correspondents, was anything but small. Broadly, this ‘mini’ budget can be summed up as a radical, tax-cutting bonanza seeking to rip up the fiscal ‘orthodoxy’, by borrowing to pay for tax cuts.

First, let us consider the main policies announced, and their impact on individual finances. The Chancellor has pledged to lower the basic rate of income tax by 1%, scrap the highest rate of income tax altogether, cancel stamp duty payments on house sales under £250,000, and scrap the moratorium on limits to bankers’ bonuses. The Treasury will also cancel the proposed rise of Corporation Tax from 19% to 25% due next April, as well as scrap the upcoming National Insurance rise. As such, the planned Health and Social Care Levy, money collected from NI, is lost in this budget, though Kwarteng said he plans to pay for this with borrowing too. The Government plans to cover lost revenue from tax cuts through Treasury borrowing, along with the extensive costs of the energy price guarantee announced earlier this month. This budget is justified by PM Liz Truss as a fiscal shift to stimulate economic growth by making the UK more “attractive” to foreign investment. But how does this budget help individuals?

In the short term, some individuals are set to benefit more from this budget than others. As students, unless you are buying a house or earning more than £12,571 a year, then the only positive impact on your individual finances is the energy price cap freeze. Whereas according to government estimates, the richest 1% are set to benefit far greater from tax cuts. As the Government has openly acknowledged, this budget moves from fiscal ‘redistribution’ policies, to what critics call ‘trickle-down economics’ – an effort to increase the economy for everyone, rather than distribute a smaller economy more fairly.

This budget is justified by PM Liz Truss as a fiscal shift to stimulate economic growth by making the UK more “attractive” to foreign investment. But how does this budget help individuals?

As expected, Labour has launched a scathing attack on what they say are tax-cutting measures set to make the wealthy richer, and further call for a windfall tax on oil and gas company profits to pay for the energy price cap freeze. In many ways, this sentiment has been echoed by leading economists, who are equally concerned by extensive state borrowing during what is technically another recession.

In the long term, there is a fear among opposition MPs and independent policy analysts (like the Resolution foundation) that working people will have to fit the bill for borrowing eventually, without seeing any personal economic benefit in the immediate term.

Despite the support of most Tory MPs and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury Chris Philip, who on BBC Radio 4 said “You can’t tax your way to growth”, other leading economists are left unconvinced. The Institute for Fiscal Studies, for example, have forecasted state borrowing will skyrocket to £190 billion this financial year, and believe Kwarteng is “betting the house” with this announcement. Similarly, the Resolution foundation, a think tank, has warned this loosening of fiscal policy (tax cuts) will force the Bank of England to tighten monetary policy further. As interest rates have already risen to 2.25%, this budget is likely to have an adverse effect on many individual borrowers in the months ahead.

Even business groups strongly in favour of tax cuts, like the Convention of British Industry (CBI), call for an action plan for stimulating economic growth, as tax cuts will not immediately solve everything. The Government is relying on foreign companies to find the UK ‘attractive’ as an investment opportunity, but without any detail on which sectors are desired to kickstart UK economic growth, or how the workforce will be re-educated. The fundamental omissions in this ‘plan for growth’ have not been missed by international markets, as the value of the pound falls to a 40 year low against the dollar.

What might this ‘mini’ budget mean for Labour’s position in the polls? As the Labour Conference comes to a close, Keir Starmer is expected to capitalise on the political chasm this budget has illustrated between the policies of Labour and the Conservatives, bringing the Labour’s party image together. Recent Yougov polling has suggested the opposition is currently benefiting from a 33 point lead. Whether this budget helps to convince the electorate of Labour’s economic credentials in the long-term remains to be seen.

Image: US Embassy U.K. via Flickr