Director spotlight: Jacques Demy

By Matthew Dodd

The filmmakers who emerged from the French New Wave – Francois Truffaut, Jean-Luc Godard and Eric Rohmer to name a few – are understandably and quite rightfully counted amongst the most influential and transformative in the history of the medium. Yet, nestled among these names is one too often overlooked, frequently forgotten and unjustifiably dismissed: Jacques Demy. Having emerged from a set whose focus, across the 1960s, became increasingly political, widespread critical consensus treated Demy for many years as something of an aberration. Whilst ‘serious’ filmmakers such as Godard were boycotting at Cannes in protest of workers’ rights – famously taunting critics at the 1968 festival, ‘I’m talking about solidarity with the students and workers, and you’re talking about tracking shots and close ups!’ – Demy was meticulously constructing iridescent homages to the Hollywood musicals of yesteryear. Nevertheless, in the 30 years since his death, Demy’s reputation has only grown, and his place as one of the greatest and, crucially, most humanistic directors of his generation seems almost secured.

Demy is perhaps best remembered for a diptych of musicals produced in 1964 and 67 respectively: The Umbrellas of Cherbourg and The Young Girls of Rochefort, which are loosely connected by actors, places and style. The former of the two in particular represents a high point, not just of Demy’s career, but of the musical genre as a whole. A straightforward but strikingly singular tale of first love, Umbrellas follows two young lovers, Guy and Genevieve, who are separated by circumstance, only to reunite at the film’s end, both having found happiness in their own way. It is a tragic and soaringly romantic tale which treads the line between realism and fantasy deftly. It is also one that left a lingering impression on one viewer, the director Damien Chazelle, who would broadly adapt many of Umbrellas’ quirks into his Oscar-winning La La Land. Demy’s genius lies in his visual style. For him, the streets of Cherbourg are an orgiastic celebration of colour, light, life, love and heartbreak. As Guy cycles out of the garage at which he works, the moonlight that dapples the cobblestones blends with the colour of his jeans; the pinks of Genevieve’s handknit turtleneck will merge with the walls of her mother’s umbrella shop before complimenting perfectly the ornate blue wallpaper of the dining room into which she walks. His worlds take nothing for granted and treat all life as worthy of musical splendour. He points his singularly empathetic eye at the world in all its mundanity – his stories are those of mechanics, sex workers, shop assistants and travelling musicians – and places such banal existence as the very height of cinematic romance. He constructs films which are at once grand musical fantasias and achingly realist stories about the limitations of cinema’s romantic dreams.

He points his singularly empathetic eye at the world in all its mundanity – his stories are those of mechanics, sex workers, shop assistants and travelling musicians – and places such banal existence as the very height of cinematic romance

The end of Umbrellas, in which Guy and Genevieve reunite for the final time, is the greatest testament to Demy’s humanistic talent. The two lovers who once meant everything to one another – ‘I would have died for him, so why aren’t I dead?’ Genevieve asks her mother – exchange the simplest of pleasantries at a petrol station before extricating themselves from the other’s life for ever. There is a moment in particular, when Genevieve asks whether Guy would like to meet the daughter she had birthed in his absence, when the hook of Michel Legrand’s theme ‘I Will Wait For You’ begins to play, that stands among the most powerful few seconds in cinematic history. As Guy shakes his head, he shuts off a whole universe of potentiality; he puts a stop to any notions of the broad, all-consuming romance that cinema wants us to believe in. The messy, banal but equally broad and all-consuming facts of reality encroach on the most beautiful love story ever told. This is not the real tragic turn, however. That comes in the next few moments, as Guy’s wife and young son arrive and crowd him with love before returning home together. Demy shows us that the tragedy of youthful, operatic romance is not that it ends: it’s that love doesn’t end with it. That we are doomed to keep loving and keep losing until we die. That we will not wait for each other, that we will move on. The last words this Romeo and Juliet say to one another are nothing along the lines of ‘thus with a kiss I die’; they are a simple ‘are you doing well?’ and an immeasurably tragic ‘yes, very well.’

Demy’s other major film, The Young Girls of Rochefort, is a lighter but, in many ways, far denser work. It is a musical which turns the port of Rochefort into a soundstage: town squares and pavements become stages, their players taking the form of townsfolk, travellers and soldiers, all joined in one joyous tapestry of provincial life. This is a world of primary colours, of architecture designed for dancing. It is a film which soars with the same transcendent romance as Umbrellas; yet, rather than bring the audience to the basest depths of melancholia, Demy playfully dances around tropes and convention without ever dipping below the register of unbridled joy. Coincidence is the governing force in this tale of two sisters and their eternal quest for romance, drama and the stage. Demy centres this grand melodrama around the lived-in geography of the town and specifically one central café, in which star-crossed lovers just miss each other, poets wax lyrical on the feminine ideal and axe murderers drink undiscovered. It’s this decision which makes Rochefort above all a powerful evocation of community and togetherness, an evocation that, when coupled with its romance, renders the film ceaselessly uplifting and life-affirming. It is a visual quintessence of joy. To call Demy a purely aesthetic filmmaker is an oversimplification as, for Demy, the aesthetic is everything: the clashing yellows and blues of an alleyway are synonymous with heartbreak; the pastel dressed and perfectly choreographed fleets of dancers in a town square the purest expression of ecstatic joy.

Demy shows us that the tragedy of youthful, operatic romance is not that it ends: it’s that love doesn’t end with it

A thousand articles might be written on Demy’s decades-spanning career, and there is much to his mythos which has been overlooked here – his fantastical musical Donkey Skin, which has become a cult Christmas classic in Demy’s native France, or his hard-boiled gambling drama Bay of Angels, to name but two. One element that, however, cannot possibly be excised from any summation of Demy is his lifelong partnership with his wife and fellow new wave icon Agnes Varda. Together, the pair were a powerful force in French cinema, embodying a boldly kind, empathetic and ultimately human attitude to filmmaking that was often lost in the new wave’s drive for political potency. Varda, whose filmography revolutionised the documentary form amongst many other things, directed films with the same kind of humanistic eye as her husband, examining subjects such as post-revolutionary Cuba, the French gleaners and Jane Birkin. She would also direct a number of films on her husband’s life and career, including a documentary, The Young Girls Turn 25, on Rochefort’s quarter-century anniversary, and an abstract biopic of Demy himself, Jacquot de Nantes, produced during his final years. Later in life, Varda recalled being questioned on how she was able to make a biographical film on her late husband: ‘One child said: “How do you remember the memory of somebody else?” And I said because I love him. And he said is that enough? And I said yes’. After Demy’s premature death from AIDs at age 59, it was Varda who kept his cinematic legacy alive as his films began to fall into obscurity by the end of the century, his vibrant worlds not quite surviving the jump to VHS. Their partnership remains one of the most fruitful in film history, and both have more than earned their place as, in the words of Martin Scorsese, ‘Gods of Cinema’.

If you are interested in reading more on The Umbrellas of Cherbourg and situating Demy’s work in the context of musicals of the same period (1960s), check out Film & TV Editor Isabel McDermott’s article here.

Image: Wikimedia Commons