Is AI the death of creativity in film?
By Mia Stewart
In the midst of this year’s awards season, and with the Oscar nominations recently released, it has become impossible to not see the increasing contribution of AI in cinema. With two of the Best Picture nominees using AI in their films, can we expect this to become the new norm in the industry? Emilia Perez (2024) has earned thirteen nominations in total – in fact, it’s just one off from joining the likes of La La Land, Titanic, and All About Eve as one of the most Oscar-nominated films of all time. The Brutalist (2024) is also not far off with ten nominations.
The latter details the story of a Hungarian Holocaust survivor, played by Adrien Brody, who immigrates to America to build his life as an architect. Arguably the two most important elements of the film that are central to the character László Tóth’s reality – the architecture and his Hungarian identity – were altered with the use of AI in post-production. The film used AI-powered software in post sound mixing to enhance Brody’s Hungarian accent by tweaking certain vowels in the lead actor’s speech, as well as visually to generate architectural designs. It has consequently faced wide social media backlash from outraged movie lovers. Some are even calling for its use of AI to be an automatic disqualifier from the awards race.
It has always been the actors’ craft to make the audience believe in the authenticity of their performance
And yet, some have suggested this controversy has been far blown out of proportion. For example, the writer-director Brady Corbet has since weighed in, emphasising the actors’ hard work with a dialect coach to master the Hungarian speech. He claims that it was definitely a manual process in post-production, made possible through the collaboration of the sound team and the Respeecher tool. The Emilia Perez sound team also used AI voice cloning tools by the same company, Respeecher, for the actors that had to sing outside their vocal range. But this begs the question, has the magic of suspension of disbelief been lost in cinema? It has always been the actors’ craft to make the audience believe in the authenticity of their performance. However, this obsession with perfection over minor details that audiences would be naturally lenient of has in fact led to an artificially-generated portrayal of Hungarian characters – the complete opposite of the authenticity the director was searching for. These two films contribute to a wider dialogue of AI’s place in society, or more specifically within the creative industry, which is currently treading towards a dangerous overreliance on artificial intelligence. It coincides with the AI takeover of streaming services like Netflix, which use the software to enhance their algorithms for viewers.
Paul Schrader, acclaimed screenwriter of beloved classics including Taxi Driver (1976) and Raging Bull (1980) has also jumped on the bandwagon, sharing his revelation online. By sending scripts that he wrote years ago through ChatGPT and asking for improvements on them, he was able to immediately receive notes that were “as good or better” than he’d ever received from film executives. Going one step further, he asked the software to give him ideas for a Paul Schrader film, and then for other prolific filmmakers. He shared his bewilderment online at why this tool is not being utilised more in Hollywood, writing: “why should writers sit around for months searching for a good idea when AI can provide one in seconds?” However, calling scriptwriters lazy and incapable of fresh ideas feeds into a dangerous narrative that only serves Hollywood’s most powerful executives. Writers do not lack ideas, but rather necessary funding and opportunities – which are instead being channelled into artificial technology for cost-cutting at every possible corner. But you cannot put a price on human innovation.
Writers do not lack ideas, but rather necessary funding and opportunities – which are instead being channelled into artificial technology for cost-cutting at every possible corner
In another interview for The Brutalist, Corbet admits that AI was used to create “little” details that the film’s budget and schedule didn’t allow to shoot traditionally. So for some, the use of AI can be considered a great money-saving tool for lower budget or independent films. However, it does not feel like that at the moment. It feels like an attractive alternative for big, rich film executives looking to streamline labour and time costs. Where do we draw the line – is it a cheap and effective tool to have at our disposal, or is it cheating, plain and simple? The potential for AI in the future of cinema is limitless. In such a rapidly changing industry, production companies and studios that use AI are unfortunately more likely to stay in the lead of their competitors. In ten years’ time, will we see an Oscar Best Picture winner made entirely by AI?
Image: Brookstreet Pictures

