Diary of a rail commuter: strike chaos, discontent, and solidarity

By Hannah Redman

Picture the scene: you arrive at the train station with the best of intentions to tick off at least one thing from that ever-increasing reading list. Getting to the Billy B will resolve all your productivity problems, you think to yourself as you climb the steps to the platform, only to watch that vision of studying vanish before your eyes. You peer at the departures board, and your heart sinks. You mutter some expletives to yourself (well, that might just be me), and proceed to assess how long you will need to wait on a windy platform before the next train arrives. An hour, wasted. They cancelled the strikes, you think to yourself, as you are baffled by the lack of train services available to you – in reality, you ought not to be surprised, as this scenario plays out disappointingly often. 

This is my experience of commuting to Durham, and as anyone who knows me will appreciate, rail strike chaos (accompanied by the many short-notice cancellations due to lack of staff) has become my only topic of conversation, bordering on a personality trait. An affliction which I can only apologise for, especially now this is being translated into written form. But jest aside, rail strikes are a serious issue impacting workers, carers, mothers and students alike. To frame this discourse of discontent in terms of purely economic impact, as the rail minister Huw Merriman has done, is not only tone deaf but minimising of the personal disruption it causes to a myriad of social groups. I chronicled my experience of the turbulent rail services as a means of depicting how students – a group relatively ignored by mainstream media when discussing the impact of rail strikes – are affected, but this is only one story. It should not be a competition about who is affected most by rail strikes, as this is a tiresome and frankly unresolvable argument. Instead, in my view it would be more productive to examine the root causes of strike action, and how they can be resolved through negotiation rather than party politics or blaming the other side for who damages the economy the most.

A serious issue impacting workers, carers, mothers, and students

Rail strikes have been occurring on a national scale, with trade unions calling for an increase in pay whilst not degrading the terms and conditions of work for its members. Another round of train strikes were due last week, though these were called off at the last minute by the unions, citing renewed progress in talks with rail company employers. This is positive news, and there is hope a point of compromise will be reached. Certainly, this could not come soon enough for rail commuters such as myself. Even so, the prospect of rail companies trying to ‘streamline’ their operation – with one proposal arguing for the removal of train conductors, leaving just the train driver to operate the service – is deeply concerning, and in my view is rightly something rail workers should oppose. This highlights the need to consider more than the purely economic dimension of these rail disputes; the causes and impacts of rail strikes rest in the humanity of these transport services. As a young woman travelling alone, I keenly appreciate the value of having a train conductor on evening services especially, a view that unfortunately does not seem to be heard by the upper echelons of rail company management. Unions are right to strike to maintain these appropriate working conditions, alongside a pay increase in line with inflationary pressures. We should mirror our analysis of the complexity of rail strike impacts by appreciating the many valid reasons for rail workers choosing to strike.

Standing in solidarity with rail workers is something we as customers can do to implore rail companies to provide a more reliable, safe, and fully-staffed service. Is that not a small price to pay to relinquish our personalities from the shackles of rail strike complaining-duties?

Image: Fabrizio Verrecchia via Pexels