Doctor Who: a celebration

By Saffron Corcoran

Just like its hero, Doctor Who is ever-changing. Since its first episode in 1963, it has brought new stories and fresh monsters all the while adapting to its time and culture.

When the original who (1963 – 1989) ended there was a nationwide outcry for the classic character to return; however, reflecting on its ending, we can see several reasons behind the decision. The show had been falling down a vicious spiral of repetitive storylines, similar monsters, and the same problem facing the Doctor, all cumulating to declining viewership and interest. Despite the committed fans, as well as Sylvester McCoy signing on for another season, the BBC cancelled the show.

However, skipping past the unspoken 1996 movie, Doctor Who burst back onto the screen in 2005 with Christopher Eccleston and his fantastic energy. I still remember sitting on my sofa as a child watching the time vortex appear on the screen – that was 5-year-old me HOOKED!

I must endeavour to question if ‘Doctor Who’ has lost the magic it once held

Since Russel Davies’ reinvention, Doctor Who has grown and grown each season in budget and in viewership but as a long-term committed fan I must endeavour to question if Doctor Who has lost the magic it once held.

At one point or another if you are talking about Doctor Who you will be asked who your favourite doctor is. One can certainly see the pros and cons to all the Doctors, both classic and new-generation; however, despite running the risk of being classified as basic, it is clear to understand why many people, including myself, opt for the enigmatic, energetic, trench-coat-wearing David Tennant.

Whilst all the actors that have stepped into the character’s shoes have been extraordinary, the show seems to have become victim to its own popularity. The storyline and writing have arguably been slowly degrading and it seems to have lost the appeal and grip it had on numerous generations of viewers.

If we look at Eccleston’s one season, every episode had its own storyline, with fairy-tale like monsters and even the prime minister as an alien, yet they all came to link together with the season finale in which Rose became the Tardis – blowing my 6-year-old mind. An even better case is Professor River Song; her storyline lasted 3 doctors and was seamless from her introduction to her goodbye.

Though as we look at Capaldi’s Doctor and Jodie Whittaker’s tenure, the writing, plots and effects have become somewhat lost. The writers and producers have seemingly departed from their foundations and started to move towards this Hollywood style of big effects and over-the-top stories that do not work within their hour slot. It has begun to feel too busy, unfinished, or overwhelming. Steven Moffet’s final episode as writer, ‘The Day of the Doctor’, seems to perfectly pin-point the change in the show’s character. This hour-and-a-half-long special brought back fan favourites, new monsters, and a realistic storyline. It is the last of the truly golden Doctor Who episodes.

Every episode had its own storyline, with fairy-tale like monsters and even the Prime Minister as an alien

Since the ‘Day of the Doctor’ episode, the show has boomed in the US, its audience growing year by year and eventually even getting its own panel at comic con in San Francisco. While I no doubt believe that Doctor Who should be revered by everyone, it seems to have caused the show to lend itself to Americanisation, desperate to slot into the streaming services and big series hype.

The effects on the show used to be basic and limited; however, that’s what brought its magic, simple and clean visual effects. The simplicity made it feel more realistic, (despite knowing that there isn’t an intergalactic police force made up of huge rhinos), meanwhile, in the most recent seasons the effects are so extravagant that they simply cannot portray the same illusion of realism. This is perfectly exemplified through the massive explosion in ‘Legend of the Sea Devils’.

Personally, it seems after the loss of Moffet and the popularity increase in America, the BBC is desperate to go punch for punch, similar to shows like The Witcher, Game of Thrones and The Rings of Power, to show that they can produce a better show and attract more viewers. Yet the magic it once held by being simplistic, just like Star Trek, has been lost. I think due to this competitive nature, the care for the storyline and character development has been lost and placed onto its special effects and outlandish plots.

If you haven’t watched the recent episode, read at your own risk this next part! With David’s Tenant return and Moffet also resuming his place as the head writer this Whovian fan can only hope and pray that it returns to its roots. Steady-paced episodes, with simple but beautiful effects with the constant amazing acting staying put.

We will just have to wait for November 2023.

Image: Charlie Seaman via Unsplash