Demystifying Mitigating Circumstances

 

The mitigating circumstances system is designed to provide students with a mechanism for ensuring that their grades reflect their abilities when their assessment has been seriously affected by circumstances that are beyond their control. However, following complaints by students and a subsequent investigation, Palatinate has found that there are serious problems with how the system operates.

Currently it seems that a student wishing to claim mitigating circumstances has their application considered according to the arbitrary rules of whatever department controls their course, rather than the rules set down by the University. They could be given extremely misleading information and receive absolutely no communication regarding what effect their application has had on their assessment, or even if it has been received.

In the course of the investigation, Palatinate spoke to several students who had needed concessions due to unforeseen events. The Deputy Academic Registrar Sam Dale was also interviewed to represent the University. His responses were slightly restrained as he did not wish to criticise other University departments or suggest reforms prematurely before the group report on possible changes to the system is disclosed in March. However he did comment on most of the areas under question. If you wish to claim for mitigating circumstances you must submit a form to your department’s Board of Examiners before their meeting that precedes the assessment in question. They will then decide whether your circumstances are serious enough to warrant a free pass to the next year or an upgrade to your degree classification if your marks are deficient. Definitive details of the process that is followed and aspects of the system that operate throughout the University are supplied online.

However, Palatinate found that when asked, several departments’ policies regarding how they dealt with students were very different to what they were meant to be. For example, the Archaeology Department stated that claims for concession due to illness would not be considered unless accompanied by a doctor’s note. Yet the guidelines clearly state that “submissions will not be discounted simply because they are not supported by independent evidence”.

More bizarrely, the Law School stated that it would not answer a number of questions about how it dealt with mitigating circumstances because this would “relate directly to the material exercise of the Board’s discretion, which is always exercised on the basis of all the facts of the individual case”. This suggests that the Law School declined to answer questions about how they deal with students because this may prevent their Board from enacting the policy they choose for each individual under consideration. Yet the questions merely required answers that adhered to University guidelines, and should not be subject to the discretion of each department’s board. The implication is that the Law School does not have a consistent policy that adheres to University guidelines when it should do. It seems that the Law Department, and several others, is a law unto itself.

The result is that students have to face a different policy depending on which department is in control of their degree, that this policy may not correspond to what is meant to be University policy, and that the policy is not what they were expecting. When asked to comment, the Deputy Academic Registrar Sam Dale stated that:

“Of course we would expect departments to correspond with the guidance set down.” When asked whether the system needed to be reformed because departments were clearly not following University guidelines, he added, “I’m not going to make a judgement about where I sit on this debate until the work is done”.

Even more distressingly, Palatinate received a complaint from a student who had been treated in a way directly contradicting both the published University guidelines and the policy of any department that responded to the Palatinate investigation. None of the departments stated that evidence was essential to obtain mitigating circumstances when a student was suffering from bereavement, and the official guidelines correspond to this. But one anonymous student was told their claim was undermined predominantly because they had not provided evidence that both family members and friends had passed away in the run up to exams. The student was extremely distressed:

“I was insulted that they asked me to provide evidence that people had died. It’s very hard to do this for close friends while their families are grieving.”

This implies a lack of sensitivity by several of the University departments, ignoring the University guidelines that are created for such upsetting circumstances.

A lack of clarity in what students need to make a successful claim appears to be another vital flaw to the current system. The online guidelines suggest that evidence of mitigating events should be “submitted with the form if appropriate”, but quickly go on to specify that “submissions will be discounted simply because there they are not supported by independent evidence: in some entirely valid circumstances there is no independent evidence that can be brought”.

This description is contrary to the experience of the vast majority of those using mitigating circumstances, several stating that a case rests on or is useless without some sort of evidence; even in a case of bereavement. In the words of one anonymous student, “I questioned the emphasis on the need for evidence when the handbook stresses that people won’t be penalised for no evidence”. The University seems to be giving students false information about what is required for a concession, undermining students’ efforts before they have even begun. Mr Dale understood the problem and sympathised with students who felt that they had been misinformed, adding, “We might want to address the wording, in particular if its causing students distress, as that’s the last thing in the world that a university like Durham would want to do”.

Others felt that a lack of transparency extended far past the deficiencies of the official guidelines. In the build up to exams last year, Modern Languages student William Lucas suffered a chemical burn to his cornea. After submitting an application for mitigating circumstances, he received absolutely no communication from the Modern Languages department or any other part of the University about it. There was no confirmation of whether his application had been successful or even whether it had been received:

 “The lack of communication increased what was already a stressful time for me in the build-up to exams. I don’t know whether this happens to every student applying for mitigating circumstances, but if it does, it really needs to be resolved.”

To the credit of the University authorities, the system is under review. A working group has been established and will report its findings in March 2010. One of the members of the group is Mr Dale, who stressed that it is not assured that anything will change. “We could fundamentally re-write everything, or we could say that it seems to be OK”.

There are two main areas of fault with the current system. Firstly, the system is riddled with contradictions, conflicting between how academic departments think the system works, how the online guidelines state the system works, and how the system actually works in real life. The second problem consists of a striking lack of clarity on behalf of the University: the ambiguous nature of the online guidelines, and lack of communication to students who are attempting to claim mitigating circumstances.”

Students must be made more fully aware of what is required for a successful application and when the best time to submit a request is. More advertising is needed and the guidelines must be much clearer about how the system operates. Finally, academic departments must be made to adhere to the rules set down by the University, so that students with mitigating circumstances receive a fair chance.

It is still not known whether the working group will advocate reform of the system, but since their recommendations will not be implemented until the academic year 2010/2011 one thing is for sure: it will be some time until these problems with the system are resolved.